Reviews for East On Main in Mattituck, NY
Food was excellent And service was great too!
The food is so-so on a good day. The short ribs are tough and the salmon is dry. Try the Steak sandwich. Seemed to be the best... way to go. Read more
First time here. Had the stuffed pork chop and friend had lobster risotto. Both were delicious! Reason only gave 3 stars is due... to the overall lack of ambiance and paper napkins!! $36 entrees deserve linen!l napkins!! Would probably only do takeout, if Iever go back, because of those reasons. Read more
We pass this place all time. Finally decided to come back after having it at a catered event last night. (Which was very good) I... was pleasantly surprised that the Italian was good coming from a place that you would expect to be more of a steak house. I hadthe mozzarella square. Loved the pesto they put on it. I decided to get the mushroom raviolis expecting it to be salty and mushybut it was fabulous! Better then some of the local Italian joints. Perfectly el dente… not salty and love the peas they put infor added texture. The sauce was nice and creamy. I would order it again for sure. The chicken fingers were good although theyseem to have a different breading than the catered ones we had at the party last night. The only thing I would change is theFrench fries. It would be awesome if they could make a fry closer to Hellenic or the old Omally’s. They seemed a little likefast food fries at best but at least the main food was terrific. I would recommend this place to anyone. Lookong forward tocoming back tomorrow! Read more
This place was a great all around experience. The "hostess" showed us a magic trick upon arrival. Drinks, food and service were... all top notch. My husband and I were commenting on how we really appreciated the high level of attention to detail andprepandemic food service. Well done East on Main. We will be back. Read more
I've never been disappointed here. Their onion soup is one of the best I have ever had. The service has always been friendly and... capable. I need to visit this place more often; I think I have been missing something. Read more
We had a party for about 50 people. Stephanie, Tony, and their team made a meaningful party special for all who attended. Their... communication throughout the planning was always very clear and timely. We arrived to a warm welcome and were taken care of fromstart to finish by a professional, caring, and fun team. We didn’t hear any complaints from the guests, only joy andgratitude. The East on Main team made it so there were no concerns, only a good time with delicious food and drinks. I recommendthis place for not only dinner but to hold an event. I look forward to the next party at East on Main. Read more
Good food. Shaved corned beef on the Reuben. Nice staff.