Reviews for Goldberg's Famous Bagels in Mattituck, NY
5 out of 5 Definitely would recommend
Great Bagels feels like you're in New York City got to get there early so the breakfast on the line is always big
I?m a local and I tried calling in to place an order for pick up and the response was ?sorry bud you need to come here and wait... in line ?. I was calling because I wouldn?t be out there for another hour knowing they were busy, did not like his tone , veryrude, and ridiculous that you can?t place an order over the phone. Read more
Worst bagel I've ever had and I've had many bagels in my day. The bagel was about 3 days old and very stale which is sad since... we visited at 6:45AM when the bagels should all be fresh. Only thing that made it edible was the large amount of cream cheesethey put. Read more
Hands down this place has the best bagels on Long Island. I lived on Long Island all my life in various towns. The bagels at... Goldbergs are so flavorful and I'm talking about the bagel itself not what they put on it. They are light and airy and not heavyand dense and doughy. Read more
Popular spot which means busy, but it's that way for a reason. Bagels, bagel sandwiches of countless varieties, plenty of... schmears, wraps, baked goods and snacks. Great for breakfast sandwiches. There was a bagel sandwich missing from our order onthis visit, but our friends that live near by and come here often have not had problems... Mistakes happen and given the volumeon a busy Saturday, it's easily forgiven. I'll be back! Read more
Decent bagel. Been to a bunch of thier locations. This is a better one. Bagels are consistent at all locations, a little harder... than I would like. But not horrible. Clean inside. Read more
I just came from there, I ordered six bagels to go and the girl behind counter asked me if I wanted any spreads. I told her yes,... I?ll take a half pound of regular cream cheese and a quarter pound of the lox spread. I literally pointed to the sample size containers that are on the counter. I come home to the sliced lox filets. ??????????? Not a huge problem, I wonder if I paidmore for that. Twenty-three dollars for six bagels and half pound of cream cheese and whatever the lox cost, pretty steep. Read more