Reviews for Mister Pizza in Mayfield, NY

Carol Johnston 1 year ago

Yummy pizza and dinners...eat in or take out.

showtime824 showtime824 1 year ago

Great pizza,wings and owners,,, a favorite of ours

Joshua Schulman 1 year ago

Solid pizza. Wings were really good too.

Mike Nelson 1 year ago

All the meals are FANTASTIC (HOT and Yummy) The atmosphere is relaxing (knotty pine). We have had both Sandy and Sherry for... waitstaff (both knock it out of the park). See You Soon. Sharon and Mike Read more

Roger Huseland 2 years ago

My wife and I both ordered lasagna dinners for dine in last week and the salad was great as well as the lasagna dinners. Our... server was very personable and helpful! Thanks Read more

Christopher Wilson 2 years ago

Consistency is key and this place has it. While the quality of food at most pizza places around here has it's ebbs and flows,... you know what to expect from Mr Pizza. And when you order your wings crispy, they actually come crispy, not a soggy vessel forthe sauce most places have them swimming in. Read more

Matthew Stoodley 4 years ago

Have not dined in yet. Had take out twice. Clean kitchen and clean take out area. The pizza is really good. Veggie pizza was a... little sloppy due to too many ingredients but delicious. Hawaiin pizza is very good. Garlic-Parm wings are very good. The garlicis not too strong and plenty of parmesan flavor. Read more

Edward Symack 7 years ago

Me and my girlfriend planned on ordering pizza and wings for diner. Which is kind of a treat for us. We placed the order picked... it up on time. Buy when we returned home and opened the boxes, we saw that the chicken wings were small, so small that we kindof laughed about it. The price u pay for the size of the chicken wing they give you is ridiculous. I have ordered food from manydifferent places and I never seen a chicken wing this small. So it was very disappointing. The pizza was good and the wings weregood but it was kind of rip off. I don't usually complain but I will never order chicken wings from there again. Read more