Reviews for Nino’s Pizza Festival in Mays Landing, NJ

This is an honest review, not meant to be mean, just genuinely honest. After a long day of working, we ordered from Ninos after... reading the reviews. We saw that people spoke highly of this establishment so we decided to give it a try. After calling Irealized that I never asked for a total, no problem either way we were going to buy what we ordered. So when we picked up foodthey let us know that our pizza & wings came up to $48. I thought this was a bit much but then I considered inflation. We justhoped that the food was worth it. When it comes to the food, I was a bit disappointed in the taste of the pizza. From thepictures online the pizza looks very robust and appetizing, but when we got our pizza, it was very thin and tasted like it satin the oven for too long. The crust was very hard, and there was not much taste. The wings also were really hard and dried outand there was not much sauce on the wings. I felt as though they did not put any sauce on there because the chicken was so dry.My family will most likely not be peering from here again for a while, at least. We came from a place with very very good pizzaand it just so happened that this was not a hit and not worth the amount of money we spent on it. Good luck to Ninos. Read more

Friendly staff, good food and bargain prices for 2 slices of pizza with a 12oz drink for $5.00.

I've had the pizza, cheese steak. and Stromboli. All are good. The one thing I cant seem to find in mays landing is cheese... fries done the right way at a pizza place. You make the fries put the cheese on top in a aluminum container, slide them into thepizza oven and a few minutes later perfection. Much better then soggy fries in a stiraphome container . If you change yourmethod please let me know and I'll be first in line to try it out. Read more

Excellent food and wonderful personal service. They explained the difference between a pizza turn over and Pisone. The turn... over isn't deep fried. I really enjoy it here. Read more

Best pizza in mays landing hands down. Very respectful and understanding staff. My go to for food here.

I?ll tell you what? I?m not very easily impressed with a lot of pizza places in the area however, Ninos knows what the deal is.... I just got a thick crust pizza (pan pizza) and let me tell you this has got to be one of the BEST pies I?ve ever sunk my chopsinto! I don?t know what my man does in there but whatever it is, he better keep doing it! Everything I?ve ever got from here wasdelicious but this thick crust pie is so incredible these other pizza places better start taking notes!!!???????????????????????? Read more

I've ordered from Ninos many times and the pizza is always good! Recently tried their thick pan pizza and buffalo wings. They... did not disappoint! Very much enjoyed the food and fast delivery ???????????? Read more

Ordering and pick up was fast service. Ordered pizza with olives on it and you can tell they added it on after it was baked.... They could of just kept the olives off they taste right out the jar which is grosz on pizza. Sadly I'll stick to dominos forolives on pizza. Read more