Reviews for Crosby's in Mayville, NY
Gas pumps are all pumping at a trickle pace. They say it's cold out, but this is unacceptable, kwik stop half a mile away was... having no problem with their pumps. Get it together. Read more
Cleanest Crosby store in town,
This store is nothing short of completely fabulous! Cheerful and helpful crew, reasonable prices, and they always have exactly... what I'm looking for! Read more
Pizza is consistently good, wings were excellent , crunchy and plenty of sauce!
Went to get my daughter some breakfast pizza on 8/17/19 at 745am and there wasn't any in the warmer. Asked the associate if she... had a pizza cooking and she said no but she could make one and it would take about 15 minutes. People don't have time to wait 15minutes for a slice of pizza before work! Breakfast time and no breakfast pizza doesn't make much sense to me. Read more
It's July 7th 2018 - they are currently out of 87 octane, so we decided to just get 89 and it was literally DRIPPING out of the... pump. It would taken 30 minutes to get 5 dollars worth so left at $$1.18 with a third of a gallon. A gas station should havegas, right? (face palm) Read more
My boyfriend and I both got turkey subs and ended up extremely sick. Heard other complaints from locals. Would not recommend.
No one answers the phones when you call and when the order was placed online they messed up the entire order including sending a... blt with no lettuce or tomatoes on it, 10.99 for a few whimsy pieces of bacon a bun and some onion. Never been more disappointedmy daughter hates the pizza because instead of half cheese they did all pepperoni. Read more