Reviews for The Mill Steak and Spirits in McCall, ID
Absolutely amazing service and food! Being a local for years I finally ate at The Mill! Food tasted absolutely delicious, came... out fast and hot, our server was so kind. I get super nervous going into new restaurants with having a dairy allergy, our serverwas nothing but accommodating and made sure I was able to enjoy my meal without the worry. 10/10 recommend this place to anybodywho?s looking for great steaks and a great atmosphere! Read more
Atmosphere is fantastic, so much to see if you look around. Food and drinks we good, we got two prime ribs and they were done... right. I was unable to finish which I blame on a bag of Stacy cake cookies. Manhattan had some ice in it which was a littleweird but it was still good. They were short staffed as everyone is these days and the employees that were there did a greatjob of checking in on us often. Read more
This is an honest write up. Sometimes the truth hurts. The atmosphere was great. The food...... $40 for a New York steak that... had NO flavor...just a sprinkle of pepper but not enough tobtaste just see the attempt. don't waste your hard earned money onit. Calamari was decent.. but the sauce was something you get from Panda Express not a true Calamari dipping sauce. Fries(potato bites) were good again could use some seasoning. The wife's fish and chips.. The fish was very fluffy and melted inyour mouth! The drinks were not stiff. We spent over $110 for a dinner for 2 and for that kind of money you expect food withflavor. The staff was very nice and professional without being over bearing but keeping an eye on drinks and making sure theywere refilled before empty and having you wait. Read more
The food was awful. We got steak medallions, salmon and fettuccine Alfredo. Both the steak and salmon were not fresh, likely... frozen and thawed. The salmon was over cooked and the steak medallions were raw to rare when I requested medium. I mean, thefood was so bad we ate 2 bites and couldn?t do any more. And it was EXPENSIVE to be that bad was not a good experience. This hasnever happened to me where it?s that bad that I just won?t eat anymore. The fettuccine Alfredo was bare able but the noodleswere broken into 2? sticks?why ??????? odd. We were rushed to order and then neglected when our food was delivered so waitedFORVER to close out and leave. The bar area with the fireplace is amazing! I recommend going for a drink and hanging out in thebar and that?s it. Didn?t know we could eat in the bar area, which would?ve been cool. Instead we were in the corner of someroom squeezed in ton a time table for 2 but had 4 of us? Read more
Great ambiance, feels like a local hangout. Do not expect anything super fancy, it?s kind of 1980?s in terms of the presentation... on the plate. However the food is good and the steaks are good quality and well cooked. Drinks are stiff and come out quick.Staff are super friendly and we enjoyed a relaxing evening. We recommend going ahead and having dinner in the bar area aroundthe fireplace. Read more
We come to The Mill every few years when we vacation in McCall. We were a little hesitant this year because of some recent... negative reviews but decided to stay with tradition and are happy we did. The service was exceptional and every staff memberhelpful and friendly. Some of our order included chicken wings, calamari, steak medallions and rib eye steak. Everything wasgreat and our steaks were perfectly prepared exactly as ordered. We will definitely be back and highly recommend thisestablishment. Read more
I don?t usually write reviews on restaurants, but I am so extremely disappointed with this restaurant that I feel others should... know. We went to dinner here for our honeymoon thinking that it would be a nice steak & seafood restaurant (I mean, by theprices we assumed they were really good!) but we were very mistaken. We were seated in a smoky room, served sloppy, bad qualityfood, and then charged a crazy amount. I?m fine with high-priced food but only if the food deserved it. This food was some ofthe worst quality food I?d ever tasted at a restaurant. Not even joking. My husband ordered the $38 prime rib and about half ofit was this gross roast beef looking slab of meat along with a huge chunk of fat. Definitely not a $38 worthy steak. We made themistake of coming here for our honeymoon. We just hope no one else makes this mistake. Just because the prices are high DOES NOTmean they serve good food. Read more
This is the most special place! Everything was amazing from the fresh salad and flavorful dressing gs, to the best old fashioned... I have ever had, the best prime rib, amazing decadent chocolate cake. Piano playing but casual, comfortable western atmosphere.Superb! Will be coming back for sure! Read more
