Reviews for Cicily's Pastaria & Grill in Medford, OR

Everyone in my family loves this place. Saturday night was the first time for my wife and I, now we love it too! We only got... spaghetti and meatballs, (stick with what you know on the first try) it was AMAZING! The service could have been better, I feellike our waiter forgot about our table a few times... food and drinks were great, though, can't wait to go again and give itanother shot! Overall a wonderful experience! Read more

Cheap food sold at high prices. Definitely not exceptional, as stated on their website. One would expect their pasta to be... fresh, house-made pasta as there restaurant name has "pastaria" in it, but it's just cheap, store-bought pasta. The food wasmediocre at best, and the wine selection was underwhelming and WAY overpriced (a cheap bottle of white wine I get at the storefor $8 was sold at $40!). The server was super nice, however, and the the ambiance is nice too. But when I came in the frontdoor and saw the special beer was Coors, I knew this establishment was masquerading as a nice restaurant. It's basically a localversion of Olive Garden. Read more

We had dinner here last night and one of the gentlemen we dined with found 2 pieces of a human tooth in his antipasto. We told... the waiter and the staff went by us 3 times with teeth in hand. They gave him 2 shots of tequila to rinse his mouth out andthen gave him a "discount" on his meal. There were 4 couples, all on separate checks. I am appalled at the lack of concern andthe fact they still brought our food to eat. I will NEVER eat here again, nor will I recommend it to anyone. They could havehandled this a lot better and in hindsight, we should have got up and walked out. If you choose to eat here, chewcarefully. UPDATE: The only meal that was discounted was his. There was a vein in the "bone" or "cartilage" and after seeingit made eating the meal that was brought out after difficult. I appreciate that you contacted your suppliers, however, it couldhave been handled a lot better than it was. The waiter we had was good and it was obvious he did not know how to handle thesituation, but he did a good job of checking on the gentleman that had the issue. We should have been given the option to stayand eat or if we wanted to leave. We weren't given any options actually. I understand things happen out of our control,however, it is how they are dealt with that we remember. Read more

Great Service! Great Environment! Delicious Water! Terrible Bread... Not sure if it wasn't cooked all the way or that's how it... normally comes. Getting charged $5.00 for adding pesto to a dish is a little pricey, wouldn't ya say? Considering I'msubstituting Alfredo Sauce for it. Why is there no Dish with Pesto? $20 bucks for a dish and no left overs. Yikes... Definitelynot returning. Thanks. Read more

Waited over an hour for Shrimp Alfredo with hair in it and Chicken Parmigiano with burnt marinara sauce. Waiter was awesome but... the rest was disappointing to say the least Read more

Update 4/26/22. Had their salmon this time. Truly impressive! Cooked to perfection, great flavor, attentive service. Update... 3/10/22 Service was really great, very pleasant waitress. Food was delicious and came out quickly even during the lunch hour.The entire experience was very nice! Great job guys! Previous review: Always good food. Fresh salad, great bread, tastypasta. If you're in the mood for quality Italian food, you won't be disappointed. Read more

We were greeted and seated quickly. Our waitress was super kind but it too 45 minutes to get bread and salad. And dinner took... another 30 minutes. We entered at 5:30 and left at 7:40. Not by choice but I am happy to say this delay was because they werepacked. I just wish there had been a little more followup from staff. Overall I will go back just not on a Saturday night Read more

Really excellent food and good service! We got 2 paninis with side salads and the portions were good and both were very tasty!