Reviews for Amici's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Melbourne, FL

This review is for Chef's Table : My first visit was amazing. Everything tasted amazing and the service and atmosphere was nice.... My second visit was the complete opposite experience. After waiting over 30 minutes over our scheduled dinner we were asked tosit at the accompanying restaurant Amici's. The atmosphere was not the same nor was the service. Our waiter just seemed to notwant to be there - the $60+ Ribeye was bland. I decided I would save it and try to salvage what I could of it at home. Thewaiter insisted on packaging up the leftover food and when it came back half of the steak was gone. Read more

Made our first visit at the recommendation of a friend. Food was wonderful and service was impeccable. Easy to hold a... conversation at the table. Staff is very friendly and time to complete a meal is almost perfect, without waiting too long orfeeling rushed. Can't wait to go again and try the pizza next time, which looked and smelled wonderful. But, then again, thepasta dishes we had were superb! Touch choice. Read more

Sat at the bar for a quick martini and sat forever. Not busy just a few at the bar. I had to call to have someone come to the... bar and the guy took my call looked right at me as I said I need a drink at the bar....he hung up the phone on me. He knowledgea white couple that walked in afterwards. Clearly, wealthy Asians are NOT accepted here. Read more

This review is for The Chef's Table (part of Amicis). The Ribeye was amazing as well as the Lobster Risotto ????. The atmosphere... is intimate, warm and the service was very much on point. Read more

We ate here after hurricane Ian. The staff was amazing and the food was hands down the best we have had in the area. My husband,... son ad my food was absolutely AMAZING. Our server was Austin G. He was very polite, attentive, funny and just great. Y’all Ican’t stress enough how great their diablo marinara sauce was. Also, my pizza was fantastic. Do yourself a favor and checkthem out. Read more

Eric was the best! He was very attentive, hospitable and even charmed my grandma. Would definitely recommend this spot and they... have great homemade food. The bakery and wine cellar are great as well. Read more

A friend recommended this place to me and it did not disappoint. The restaurant is cozy and I enjoyed looking at the artwork on... the walls. The hostess and our server was very friendly and attentive. We were told a 25 min wait but they sat us after only 5mins. My table ordered manicotti with a side of sausage and chicken parm with fettuccine Alfredo. Both dishes were excellent! Read more

When I want to dine out and splurge, Amici's is on the list. I always get the Shrimp Parmesan and add fettuccini alfredo as the... side. The two together are so tasty. My complaints are that I guess there isn't hosting in the afternoons and I have to standawkwardly waiting for someone to see me to be seated because of the wall by the host stand that blocks the view from everyoneelse working there (terrible design). Also, the fettuccini alfredo (even though I order it all the time) is very al dente to thepoint of uncooked sections of pasta sticking together. Also, the bread isn't that great and they ration it - I eat alonenormally and they only give me a couple slices. That's chincy. But I like the servers, the pasta truffles are divine, and I dolove the shrimp parm. Read more