Reviews for Blackstone Steakhouse in Melville, NY
Excellent dinner! We enjoyed a sushi appetizer, a luxurious steak dinner and a perfect cheesecake dessert. We were celebrating... our anniversary so we got a little extra surprise! If you’re celebrating and want to feel pampered, I recommend checking thissteak house out. Amazing service, strong drinks and a lovely wine selection. We will be back!! Read more
Phenomenal food. Great service. Great atmosphere. Very busy but still great service from the instant you walk in the door. Valet... was smoking...might be an issue for some. After golf my foursome had Steaks, lobster, sushi, sashimi with mashed potatoes,creamed spinach, french fries and drinks. My drink was too heavy on the alcohol but everything else was perfect. I shouldn't getlit off of 1 gin and tonic... Read more
I went in a large party of 20+ people. We had a set menu, so this review is ONLY based on the services and food of that menu. It... may be different for those who come with a partner or just with their family. Nonetheless, the waiters and waitresses were allpolite and patient. The food were excellent too. Although the portions size were small, by the end of the meal, it was actuallyjust right. Those who like to eat more may want to order an extra dish or two. The foods were delivered in a timely manner, wedid not wait too long in-between each dish. As for the attire, you may come in a casual attire. However, majority of the peoplecome in a bit dressed up (you can do a business-casual or just a button down shirt with jeans). Read more
I started the night at the bar having drinks with my close friends. Our bartenders Amanda and Pete were very good, friendly and... made excellent cocktails. When we moved to a table for dinner, our waiter Serano was excellent as well. This establishment isbusy, loud and a solid place to meet up. There is definitely a bar scene going on here. The decor is really nice and wellappointed. However the food is the real star. The filet mignon, Sushi, Octopus and Creamed Spinach were prepared perfectly -extremely delicious. The desserts were good as well. It was a good night. We ended up finishing our drinks at the bar. Theonly thing that I didn't like was how they shut the place down. It immediately and told everyone they had to leave....a littletoo aggressive. We spent close to $1000 as a group. It wasn't a nice last impression. However a positive dining experienceoverall. Read more
Celebrated 2022 Valentine’s Day ! Had reservation at 6 pm . Food was so so delicious! Service ok . I really was so... disappointed ( overwhelmed, overcrowded, they added extra tables ) . I basically had romantic valentines dinner with othercouple who were so close to us !!! ) really my suggestion for manager: you should tell people that restaurant will be add extratables and will be overcrowded) spent $400 for delicious dinner but not so happy about all set up for tables ! Do t recommendcelebrating any special day at this restaurant. Read more
Possibly one of the most classy, romantic, and high quality restaurants in Long Island. We came here to celebrate my brothers... 30th birthday. The ambiance has a sexy and romantic look to it. Having gone around to many different steak houses in New York,our highest expectations are NYC Kobe beef and Peter Lugers/Bryant and Cooper-level porter house. Blackstone is different, andwe rate it 10/10 for its own reasons. Come to blackstone to get their wagu. We got the special which came with 3 differentwagus, 4oz from America, 4oz from Australia, and 4oz from Japan. The Japan one was absolutely mind erupting, melted in ourmouths, and is a flavor and sensation we will never forget. Our next favorite was the American (flavorful), and last, theAustralian (a little tough for our liking). They were all amazing and we are glad we ordered this way to try all three. You getto cook everything yourself on a hot plate too which makes it the freshest taste as possible. The sushi was also 10/10 and thesides were great too. Everything is insanely over-priced (possibly, not worth the cost… the French fries were $16 for a normalcup of French fries, we’ve had better French fries than that before so they can do better). But the overall experience wasabsolutely worth it and we would certainly come back again for special occasions. Thank you Blackstone! If you liked thisreview, check us out on Instagram @andiamoadventure :) Read more
Took my oldest son here for his 30th birthday. Had the best meal I've ever eaten in my entire life! We started our meal with... the wedge salad with blue cheese crumbles, the fatty tuna sushi, and the Kobe hot dog to pass around. The Japanese Kobe steakwas so delicious and the highlight of my meal, I will never be satisfied with a normal steak again. My son got the sampler, withthe Japanese, Australian, and American Kobe steak slices alongside a searing hot blackstone to cook them up a bit more. Themashed potatoes and french fries were also delicious, although they gave only a tiny portion which didn't reflect the heftyprice! The service was also excellent and they didn't rush us out! Read more
My family and I came here for thanksgiving. It was the best decision so we wouldn't have to cook or clean and we did not regret... the choice! For thanksgiving, they had their usual menu but more choices for the special day. We all chose the turkey dinner andadded a side of mushrooms and sweet potatoes. We devoured everything! The service was great and they might have been extra nicesince it was a holiday. I would consider coming back for a holiday if my family wanted. Read more