Reviews for Cottage Hotel of Mendon in Mendon, NY
Went here for Tuesday trivia night with friends and ordered the big Mac tacos. Food was all served cold and took a while. But in... their defense they only had one waitress. Other than being cold it was ok. The biggest upset was the fact that the followingmorning I was very ill from the food. I'm hoping to participate in trivia night again soon but now I'm very nervous about tryingtheir food again. Read more
Came to see Keith Baker and his wife Marlene. Keith was playing and singing with Jeff Clark and Paul and I thoroughly enjoyed... the show. Had a drink and enjoyed that too. Would have had dinner also but I was coming from a Celebration of Life for adeparted friend and they had refreshments afterwards. After attending that it was time to enjoy good music and friendship andthe Cottage Hotel did not disappoint. Read more
Stopped in on a whim and ended up having some of the best wings I've had in a long time. They were perfectly crispy, tons of... meat, and the tiger sauce was amazing. Staff was friendly as well. Read more
Absolutely fantastic ~ delicious food in a colorful atmosphere, great live music, & a wonderful server ~ Thank you, Hope & All!!... We'll be back ???? Read more
The food is good but inconsistent with its cooking. For example, if you ask for a medium rare burger, the burger may come medium... or medium well. The quality of ingredients is American restaurant standard and nothing to rave about but is sufficient. Thefood is American bar and grill with a slight upscale presentation. The interior decor is local-dive bar-rustic. If you're justlooking for a quick place where you can stop in and grab a bite while wearing workout clothes or jeans and a t-shirt then thisis it. This place has seen a lot of traffic over the years, so don't expect polished and new looking facilities. This includesthe restroom. Read more
We chanced upon this lovely place after a hike at Mendon park. The whole atmosphere was warm and inviting. The food especially... the pork pull burger was delicious. There was an awesome space rock band playing various medleys from trippy King Crimson jazzjams to Steely Dan. Read more
We were seated outside and a server approached quickly. She took both our drink and food orders. The drinks appeared shortly... and were never refilled. However the food was served over an hour later. Never were we advised if the restaurant wasunderstaffed or if there was another problem. The food was cold and the meat in our beef on weck sandwiches was of poor qualityand badly cooked. We will not return. Read more
Great burgers... Met an old friend for lunch and a chance to catch up. It's a feel good place with very good service.