Reviews for Angie's New York Style Pizzeria in Mentor, OH
The owner is a great guy! Great pizza!!! They have really good daily specials on pizza calzones and subs. Check it out
Its hit or miss here. Last month the pizza was really good.. today, they took an old cheese pizza an slapped some toppings on it... and reheated it and that's what I got. Straight garbage. Read more
Why have I not tried their pizza sooner?? It is so good! The sauce is slightly sweet with just enough zest, but their cheese and... dough are so delicious. They also are very generous on their toppings compared to other local pizza shops. I will definitely betreating myself to their jalapeno pizza again soon. And the guys who were working there the Saturday night I ordered were superfriendly and very helpful. Read more
I ordered Angie?s pizza for the first time and it it?s sooooo good!! Everything tastes exceptional! Definitely recommend!
We ordered online and had to order 2 toppings when we only wanted double cheese. The meatballs looked old and were rubbery, and... the pizza was still doughy on the bottom in the middle. The salad was great! The cannoli was not worth the price; it was verysmall and not stuffed all the way throughout. Read more
Just nasty pizza. Dough was not crisp or done too or bottom. Could not pick up a slice without loosing all toppings.... Definitely not NY style. I?d say the style was just bad. Italian sandwich was just as bad. Save you money. Read more
I was so excited, as this was my very first time ordering, Angie?s Pizza. I?ve heard great things about their pizza. Got my... pizza, it looked and smelled amazing. I couldn?t wait to take that first bite. The pizza was undercooked, still doughy.Absolutely nothing special.I ordered the Sicilian pizza. I should have read the read the reviews beforehand. It seems to be arunning complaint. Read more
One of our most fav pizzas in the area! Love East of Clevelander white pizza. We feel that it is the best white pizza in the... area. Staff is always very friendly. During Christmas Eve last year, they were so sweet to let us order 10 min before closing.Our family loves this place! Read more