Reviews for P & P New York Style Pizza (Mentor) in Mentor, OH

Pizza was just ok. No flavor to the sauce. Nor any spice to the pepperoni. Just blah.

Got a large cheese pizza! It tasted so good, I will be back for sure!

Closet I seen to real NY pizza in Cleveland and there really affordable keep up with great deals, I give them a 10 if I could

Update: l had P&P again at a lunch event and the traditional pie was significantly better than the sheet pizza I had... previously. The crust is very true to NY style, and the ratio of sauce/toppings to dough was perfect? I didn?t need theadditional side sauce that the owners offered. It?s one of the few places in the Mentor area to get sheet pizza from, but thedough on the sheet pizza is much thicker than expected compared to NY style. From my previous review I wanted to reiterate thatthe salad was very good? full of toppings and a generous side of dressing. The staff is also very friendly, and the restaurantis clean. I may not get the sheet pizza again, but the traditional pies and salads are easily 5 star quality. Read more

Overall our family likes this pizza a lot, but more times than not in the past 6 months the pizza has arrived cold. Contacted... through Slice app and got credit for pizza arriving cold. Great customer service and quickly handled. Completely understandbeing short staffed and will continue to give business. Read more

This pizza was boring at best. It arrived so cold it was stiff which is the antithesis of a good New York style pizza. I also... ordered extra cheese and as the photo attests I did not get that. The salad is good. Read more

Love the thin crust, personally I like it cooked a little longer for the crisper crust. The garlic sauce is great. Apparently... the garlic parmesan is homemade, guess I will be eating the wings next time. Read more

My son & I had lunch here the other day. The pizza slices were hot & fresh. The cashier who served us was friendly & hospitable.... I hope to return soon. Read more