Reviews for Nino's Sicilian Pizza in Middlebury, VT
This one of my favorite places to get pizza they have so many different options and there prices are very reasonable and the... staff are always very friendly. Read more
The pizza was EXTREMELY soggy, besides a much smaller than usual slice. When you get LUCKY, you'll eat good pizza. The... inconsistency is the standard of this place, though. Read more
This isn't a business, it's someone's hobby. Random closings, unreliable, always some "emergency." Lame excuses scribbled on a... paper plate taped to the door. Don't waste your time. American Flatbread is nearby, their wood fired pizza is great, and unlikeNino's, they show up for work. Read more
It's decent pizza and knots when you can get it. Way too often the phone is disconnected, they're abruptly closed, or they're... not accepting orders for the night. Being short staffed is one thing, but I don't understand why you can't schedule everyone tohave the same days off so you're always open when you're listed to be. How am I supposed to order your pizza if every time Icall you're unavailable? Also, the pizza quality is wildly inconsistent. The slices they have in the window are perfectly goodlooking and I way too often bring home a pizza that is twice as thick. Read more
We absolutely love their pizza. Great selection of interesting vegetarian pizzas. Staff is super friendly
Take out only. Acceptable pricing. We tried a few thin crust slices and they were good.
Best pizza is Middlebury, without a doubt. The Sicilian-style pizzas are extremely good (love the thick crust and immense cheese... portions). Prices are high but you do get great portions and fresh ingredients. They sometimes are very busy which can preventcalls going through, and their hours have changed several times without much notice in the past few years. That said, they dohave a Facebook that is regularly updated. I have had most of their speciality pizzas and all are good. Their wings (maplebalsamic are awesome) are also quite good, and they do offer salads for those looking to be healthier. If you do pick up, makesure to grab some of their homemade cinnamon bites/rolls. The perfect dessert! Read more
Made a special order- asked for ?Buffalo hot wings-plus? and was NOT disappointed, we love the pizza anyways and made a special... request on the wings- I have missed face-melting but flavorful wings and this order was en point. Can?t say enough good thingsfor this order. Read more