Reviews for Craftsman Table & Tap in Middleton, WI
Extremely refreshing to have this type of experience… every staff member was happy, friendly, and good at what they do! Fish... fry was great. Double smash burger was insane. And the brand new Brussel Sprout Toast appetizer was exceptional! Thank you Ryanand staff for a great evening. Read more
The Grilled Pork choPs ???????????? The Cheese curds Good But definitely not the best I Have Had...only because the cheese is... melted out of the crunch... Read more
Nice and spacious American eatery with indoor and outdoor dining. We tried the nachos, grilled salmon salad, chicken ranch... salad, and the mezze plate. Each of the dishes tasted great and the portions size were huge. Perfect spot for a lunch or dinner. Read more
We had fish and chips and their classic burgers with egg. The meat was cooked exactly to order, and was a good portion. All of... the food had good flavors, certainly unique. Coleslaw didn't have an overpowering vinegar flavor for example. The pickles on theburger were cucumber slices with a sweet and sour flavor, crisp and a perfect pairing with the burger. The cottage fries weredone to near perfection. The coconut cake dessert did have a long refrigerated flavor and was a tad dry. Beer selection, I couldsit here all day with all of the different flavors, profiles, styles on tap. If you can't find a beer you like at this tap, notsure you can be satisfied. Read more
We ordered the grilled salmon salad and it was not good. No seasoning, way too much buckwheat and simply no flavor. Same with... the cheeseburger max and cheeseburger mac. Also so bland. We had to salt and pepper everything just to eat it. Cheese curds weregood. Read more
Valentines update… love their tiramisu. My daughter and I visited again. It was a good day for burgers. Was told about their... tiramisu, and we were not disappointed. So rich and delectable. Not too sweet, just the right amount of richness… mouthwatering. Each time I come here I have enjoyed absolutely devine food, their comfortable atmosphere and have loved thewonderful, friendly and accommodating staff. Couldn’t ask for more! Read more
another tale where i inhale my food before taking pictures :-) i consider this a sign of how delicious the food is. the brussel... sprout salad was so filling and delicious- i woke up thinking about it again today. also, the dusted cheese fries are amazing. ihave to say, the very best part was the sauce that comes with the fries. it is SO good. overall, my boyfriend and i both had awonderful experience at craftsman! Read more
On average it takes the hostess over 5 minutes to even acknowledge us when we come in, and usually another 10 minutes before she... walks over to us. No greeting and it seems as though she's bothered that we are there. Some days there is great music playingand others the music is so terrible that it makes it difficult to dine in for me. The food is consistently good and the servicefrom the waitstaff has always been excellent. Read more