Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in Middleton, WI
NEVER COMING BACK AGAIN!!!! I get that there is a worker shortage. What I don't understand is why the workers feel compelled to... have the music playing louder than a college bar on a Saturday night. I couldn't hear the guy so the whole process took twice aslong because we both kept having to repeat ourselves. The food used to be good and now it sucks. I didn't even eat my tunasandwich because it smelled and tasted horrible Read more
I wanna start by saying I feel super bad I forgot the name of the man who served me but he can be identified as an extremely... good looking middle aged man with the best attitude Ive ever seen at a restaurant let alone a sub shop. like indescribably goodattitude. acting like hes making 100$ an hour or something. I decided to stop in today for the first time ever on therecommendation of a friend. this man made my experience amazing. I mean its almost unspeakable how good of an attitude this guyhad. he was talking to everyone in the store with the biggest smile.welcoming ppl as they come and saying I mean honestly, itseemed like undercover boss and dude dint care if ppl knew he was the CEO. defiantly an 11/10 from me this dude needs a raise.the second he realized i was new he just started walking me through everything and just making me feel super comfortable. ivenever experienced such good service, let alone at a sub shop like holy cow. regardless, if yall end up going while hes there uwill know this review is about him. I believe his name started with a D like Demetrius or something. Once again I apologize Iforgot your name if that isn't it bur bro, ur the bomb! god, just ineffable how good the service was. also the food was great.defiantly better than any of the other sub shops around and abt the same price point. dont be sleeping on this place. Read more
Not open due to construction. Would be great if you updated that for people who drove out of their way to get there. *updated:... thanks for the quick response. Totally understand unforeseen issues. Google maps said it was open, so the family was lookingforward to it. Thanks for the update. Read more
Never been to Jersey Mike's before. Demetrius made the experience above and beyond amazing. The whole staff was great too.... Definitely will be back. Read more
They were good. First time I have had a decent cheese steak in Wisconsin, roll was good, steak was good. Cheese was a little... runny. I know what a good cheese steak is because I grew up around Philly. Read more
Are you kidding me? "Jersey Mike's Subs" is always 5 stars!!! Love you guys! Try 56 if you like a bit spicy. But regular Philly... cheese steak is my favorite too. Please keep in mind, that chicken sub preparation usually takes longer than steak. Read more
Not as good as Capriotti's, but still one of the better sub shops in town. Big Kahuna Giant Size = 20 inch Philly Cheese-steak... with jalapenos and extra meat. Read more
Love Jersey Mike's!! This location is compact, hence the 4 stars on atmosphere. The staff was great!