Reviews for Johnny’s Italian Steakhouse in Middleton, WI
As a patron, I felt well received. Ambiance was on par for your typical steakhouse with high booths, dim lighting, and fairly... well controlled noise. The server had just the right amount of presence; not too interruptive and there when I needed him. Steakwas well cooked and tasted great. Portions left a bit to be desired and I left about $45 lighter and still craving more. Read more
What a wonderful dining experience. Phenomenal service provided by Marianna. We had a party of 11 and we all had everything we... needed promptly. 10 of the 11 meals arrived together. My dish, the Beef Wellington, was delayed by about 10-15 mins. Mariannaand the new manager (I forget his name) handled it in stride. We all make mistakes and they showed sincere remorse for my dinnershowing up late. Our table had such a wonderful time. That was my first beef Wellington and the evening will be one I rememberfor a long time. Easily one of the best steaks I’ve ever eaten. Read more
This is THE special place for date night. The food is the best and the service is outstanding. They will do their best to... accommodate the guests wishes. Read more
Foods and the dining environment are excellent. The only problem is the dishes are served too slowly due to shortage of hands.
First time here. We had cocktails, jim beam and tuscan sunsets. They were so very good. We had the prime rib and stuffed... shrimp. Oh yes, the stuffed mushrooms with sausage, really good! Good portions, made superbly. We even had desert, thechocolate lava cake. The only thing i didnt like was the cinnamon ice cream but my boyfriend loved it. The cake and cream wasgood enough for me! Service very good. We will return! The restaurant was so beautiful and clean. Thank you! Read more
The one spot where you can get serious class and culinary cunning in a single dining experience. Always clutch, go for the... Zucchini Fries (pro tip: get an extra side of Marinara). So many fantastic offerings, it's hard to miss with Johnny's. Enjoyed agreat Father's Day dinner the last time! The veal is for real! Read more
As always the food is amazing here. Love the ambience and decor of the restaurant. Good place to enjoy a nice formal dinner in... the burbs. Food and ambience is a 10/10 but the service is a little slow so be prepared to wait. We had the spinach artichokedip and zucchini fries and they were awesome. The crab cakes and calamari are really good too. You can’t go wrong with any ofthe steaks and pastas here. Check out Johnny’s Italian Steakhouse in Middleton, WI. Read more
Wel decorated. Warm ambiance. I had one of the best steak if my life. We were served by a very kind waitresses. By in the end we... were rushed a little bit to finish. It was a little downside to our experience. Read more