Reviews for My Sister's Kitchen in Middleton, WI
Very cute spot and very reminiscent of sitting in someone?s kitchen. Parking is basically on the road, there isn?t really a... parking lot that holds more than 5 cars. The food took a while to come out but we weren?t in a hurry. I had the southwesternwhich was excellent, everything was cooked perfectly, especially the hash browns. My husband had the stuffed French toast whichwas pretty disappointing unfortunately. It lacked any flavor and there was barely a smear of cream cheese and raspberrypreserves on the inside. No powder sugar or syrup so it was rather dry and flavorless. Definitely would not recommend that dish.My husband also ordered bacon which we ended up not getting. They were busy so rather than asking for it, we just asked it betaken off the bill which we had no issues with. One lady was working the whole place and she was very friendly and as attentiveas possible while running around. Overall, we would go again (as long as we aren?t in a hurry) but not for the French toast :)the bill was around $35 for our two dishes and two coffees. Read more
Very poor experience. We had to wait 1 hour and 15 minutes for our breakfast. The fruit platter had very litter fruit and was... overpriced. A sausage patty and two slices of bread were $10. I get it inflation is going up but this doesn?t seem right. Thefood quality does not make up for the long wait. Waiter service was OK. Read more
If you want a quick, average meal this ain't the place for you. At My Sister's Kitchen you get a full culinary experience with... delicious hearty food, classic American diner wholesomeness, and friendly service. Dianne was a treat, she took the best care ofus. Never short on a quip, this gal. My only advice: just order one pancake, not two. They are gigantic! Sip your coffee, takein the ambience, and just have yourself a nice time. Read more
Your typical breakfast place that gives way to much food. All home made and good. Don't let the appearance fool you. Get out of... the car and give it a try. Cheeseburger soup was great. Read more
Horrible experience. Breakfast was $20 a plate. Their website prices are not close to what is current. Service was very slow,... with a 20 plus minute wait for food, and slow coffee refill, we had to set our empty cups on the table edge to get the refill.Food quality was poor my hashbrowns were soggy, on our other order the American fries were basically potato chips. My dish waspeppers, hashbrowns, with cheese. I expected the pepper to be cooked with the potatoes and cheese on top. What I got was alayer of overcooked peppers, a layer soggy hashbrowns with pepper jack melted on top. The bacon was done extra crispy. Read more
Very friendly staff, and CLEAN. You could eat off the floor, its that clean! I had a very good burger, and my wife had chicken... and dumplings. She said it was good, but not through the roof good. I really like supporting small independent restaurants, and this place deserves the love. I'll be back soon to try their pie. Read more
I had the raspberry stuffed French toast. And it was stuffed ???? They out done my grandma?s cooking! This is the best breakfast... place I have been to in this town. (You can pay with a credit card) Read more
My family and I went this morning for a breakfast. The waiting is long, not only for getting a table, but also to order and get... the food. The food is good and the portions as well. Good for the price. Expect to spend more than 13 dls for dish. I found theservice very bad, we need to ask for everything, even silverware and napkins. The waiters did not offer a menu for kids to mylittle one. We saw a couple of table with kids and cayons and a piece of paper to draw; however, my little one didn?t. That wassad Read more