Reviews for Vin Santo in Middleton, WI

Jeff Henriques 2 years ago

Our favorite Italian restaurant. Warm, friendly atmosphere. Lots of great dishes. I personally love the eggplant parmesan, and... the tiramisu is out of this world. Read more

Alex Schwier 4 years ago

Love this restaurant - cozy atmosphere and delicious, fresh pasta and sauces. The lasagna is definitely worth the wait (around... half an hour). If you manage to save some room, I highly recommend the bread pudding. Read more

Jon Stewart 4 years ago

Great lasagna and great specials. We always take grandparents here because they can get their standard meals while everyone else... can try something new to the menu or a special. The bread pudding and tiramisu are far and away the best desserts in Madison.Just come hungry because each dessert is portioned for multiple people. Read more

Nathan Johnson 5 years ago

An awesome, old school, simple, and cozy little Italian restaurant. Located in downtown Middleton Vin Santo might be the best... place for Italian food in the Madison area. Staff is very attentive, friendly, and personable. Vin Santo ravioli was superb.My girlfriend went with the Campenelli with goat cheese, and tomato basil sauce. She said it was very tastey and fresh. Fordessert try the bread pudding a staple they are known for. If you are looking for great Italian food stop in and check out VinSanto. You will leave very full and satisfied. Read more

Ronald Baxa 5 years ago

Genuine Italian food in enormous proportions. Attentive and friendly staff. Recommend reservations as it is a small and popular... restaurant. Great shrimp dishes. Different lasagna recipes throughout month. Share a dessert. Big enough for 4. Read more

Patrick Jones 6 years ago

Excellent local Italian restaurant. Small romantic location. One of the best Italian places in town. Excellent Caesar Salad,... Baked Lasagna with Spicy Sausage, and Tiramisu. Read more

Alex Frost 7 years ago

This place is wonderful! All of our meals turned out amazing, and the bruchetta was great. The waitstaff was very knowledgeable... and never let a glass get empty. The owner (I think) even heard a spoon fall of the table and had the waitress bring anotherset. And the bread pudding is to die for! Will definitely be coming back. Read more

Carl Kopplin 7 years ago

Had dinner with two others. Service was good and attentive. Calamari appetizer was different (not breaded, and served in a... slightly spicy tomato sauce). Entree's were generous, pasta cooked perfectly and ingredients fresh and continued the theme of aslight twist on old favorites (my spaghetti and sausage had fresh mozzarella added). House wine was very nice. Desert, achocolate cheese cake variant, was very tasty and the portion was generous enough for three to share. I think this is one ofthe better Italian restaurants in the Madison area, and it compares well to the ones I have visited in Milwaukee. However, Ido think it is a little on the pricey side for some menu items, and you should know that (at least from what I have tried) theydo add a bit of a culinary twist on some of the standard Italian items (which I personally like, but may surprise those with aview based mostly on chain Italian). I have eaten here many times and never been dissatisfied. And while all meals have beengood, I have had some that were truly excellent (a wild boar and pasta preparation). I recommend it to friend's, and theambiance, makes it a nice setting for an imitate meal, particularity during the week when its quieter. Would give it 4.5 if thatwere an option. Read more