Reviews for Papa Pepperoni Pizza in Middletown, IN
This place glowed up! Easily one of the best pizza places in the area. their party pack is my wife's go to and we don't even... think twice. Read more
Locally owned favorite for pizza, subs and calzones! Great value and the newly renovated restaurant is very comfortable for what... ever your party size is. Read more
This place is a fantastic pizza place. Very friendly staff, clean and great price for food and drinks.
This place is great! The pizza's are wonderful, the price is very reasonable and the "topper" is the ice for the sodas. It's... little pellets and is my personal favorite. Read more
Thank you soo much for doing such a great job at the Fowler/Hale wedding! It was delish and fabulous delivery! We appreciate... you! As always?great food and great service! Thank you for making it carefree for us! We appreciate you!???? Read more
I can only speak on what we have tried so far but the pizza supper good, ham and cheese sub great, steak n cheese little bit of... fatty pieces, nachos excellent, garlic knots stop notch, spaghetti and Meatballs were ok they gave you a large portion but nota lot of taste, also didn't get a salad with it like we were supose to. The place is so clean inside they have great rewardswith the app. And the employees are very nice. Read more
Their new location is really nice. The food was amazing as usual! We got 10" Ranchero, a 10" Chicken Carbonara, and a Deluxe... calzone. And pepperoni bread sticks. I've never ordered something here that I didn't like Read more
We did the order ahead and dine in option on line. It was very convenient for our family with toddlers! The garlic knots and... cinnamon sticks are fantastic! The pizza is good, we always get the hand tossed, so I can't speak to the other types of cruststhey offer. Read more