Reviews for Coney Island Cafe in Middletown, NY
Excellent service and good menu choice in a clean environment
It is impossible for 2 coney dogs and 2 lg fries come to 19.02. I guess since last time I was here this place really changed and... time to find a new hot dog place it's a shame they were so good Read more
Excellent Hadn't been there in years, stopped in for a couple Coney dogs Just like the old days and I mean the 1960s Good... job Brings back good memories and I will be back Read more
If you're hungry for anything or sing or you got the munchies this is the place I recommend for anybody. They have breakfast all... day long till they close and their breakfast is worth diving into I personally have had their Irish eggs Benedict which wasabsolutely delicious especially with homemade corn beef hash. I have also tried their banana bread French toast which is asdelicious and super filling as you believe it is. I've also just snack down on a Coney island dog which is the best hot dog Icould recommend getting I've also had their cheeseburgers which are amazing and if you get chicken tenders from there absolutelydelicious so good there's nothing like having fresh chicken tenders made for you. Also the vibe in there is very chill it's niceto just walk in there sit down and enjoy yourself they have great atmosphere over there. Read more
Recently started job in area and was looking for a good breakfast sandwich. The sandwich was decent but I also ordered chicken... soup and a salad for lunch. Lunch, no so good. Soup tasted like dirty water with an abundance of noodles. No chicken or veggiesat all. They made the salad with big hunks of iceberg lettuce (which I hate) and there?s literally no seasoning on the chicken.Will go back if I had to for breakfast but that?s about it. The people were nice so that?s a plus. Read more
Food was good and fresh. I did uber eats and they didn't make my order until I got there
Recommended by a friend who has been living in Middletown for over 40 years, so we tried their loaded hotdogs. It was good, and... I liked the fries too. Very good prices too. Would like to try their breakfast sometime. Read more
Omg, really good food and, very nice service.