Reviews for Five Guys in Middletown, NY
I love to eat here. Always great service, the people are friendly and the food is fresh! Definitely worth it!
Five guys never seems to disappoint. The staff were really friendly and helpful. The food was amazing, and the establishment was... clean. There's not much more you would need. Read more
Great burger and fries. Veggie sandwiches are also very good. Order online if you want to beat the crowd during busy hours.
First of all, I love Five Guys, I live in Rockland County and normally go to the Nanuet location which I LOVE LOVE LOVE going... there. However, in this Middletown location, I?ve been there 3 times this 3rd time is a charm. I was there last Sunday 9/11/22 Iordered a double cheese with bacon and ?no bun? in which the cashier asked me if I have a food allergy or ?diet preference? Itold him that?s how I preferred my burger. Then he ask if there was anything else I need.....and for my husband I told him thesame burger ?BUT make it normal and with a bun? he repeat after me ?yes this one with a bun? mind you we were very hungry thisis ours after hiking first meal of the day. I collected my order once it was ready but sad to find out that BOTH are withlettuce wrap. Instead of one, it?s lettuce wrap and one with a bun just a normal burger. I never think of looking at the receiptwhile we were waiting because we never have any problem ordering food at five guys. My husband wasn?t happy we looked at thereceipt and he went back to the cashier, and told the guy that he made a mistake but don?t worry just give him the buns and hewill make it work on his own. The cashier looked at my husband as if he had 5heads and say ?I don?t think we can do that? so myhusband just ordered another burger for our son and went back to the car. As hungry as he was he didn?t even eat the burger, wecould have gone next door to Wendy?s but we wanted good burgers with sides of dissatisfaction, and disappointment because thecashier refuses to fix his mistake and told us he can?t give the bun so we can correct his mistake. And small fries are reallysmall, normally at five guys, small fries can easily be good for 2 people but not this location. We paid close to $50 for thisand my husband didn't get to eat his favorite burger smfh will not stop by this location again. Read more
I bit mixed on this review. The food came out good with tons of fries, freshly cut and hot, and burger was yummy. We ate in... and the layout is super basic. Gave the feeling like I was eating at a cafeteria. Read more
So as a chain I'm pretty impressed with 5 Guys but it's the individual store that I'm reviewing. That said, the crew here is... always really nice and the food is always consistently high quality in terms of freshness and in the preparation. I've alwaysgotten to-go but the dining area itself seems clean and well-kept. If I have a choice of fast food burger establishments in thearea, I usually go for 5 Guys. Obviously the prices are a little higher but the other guys aren't too far off and are of lessquality. Read more
Had lunch there yesterday. To be fair I was there during the 12 to 1 pm hour. So I'm sure they were extra busy. Which they were.... There was a fairly long wait for the food. The store wasn't dirty, but wasn't overly clean either. The food was pricey. A cheeseburger (which turned out to be a double burger) and a middle sized fries, was over $15. And that's without a beverage. But thefood was very good. Greasy, but that's why it tasted so good. Parking isn't drastically bad. But it isn't the easiest parkinglot to get in and out of. Worth the stop if you don't mind the high price. Read more
Whenever we can't all decide where to eat.. 5 guys is the answer! Best burgers and fries! Kids and mom are always happy here!