Reviews for Pizzaiolo by Brothers in Midland Park, NJ

This place has been around for a long time. Love it! Pizza is my main reason, a friend always gets the chicken Parm.

We ordered pizza ,ok The dough is good but the sauce and cheese just didn’t taste good .sadly I couldn’t finish one... slice Also the side free bread was dry and couldn’t eat it . Read more

Ordered a take out Stromboli for later consumption so it's half cooked. Heated it up a few hours later. It was 95% cheese. ... Couldn't see or taste the pepperoni or sausage, or the salami I asked for. I would never or a Stromboli there again... unlessI was in the mood for a big mozzarella sandwich. Very disappointed. Read more

Awful service. My wife ordered a diet coke and it tasted like they hadn't cleaned the machine in years. We were waiting to... order for 15 minutes while people who were seated after us received their food. Our server passed our table 3 times withouttaking our order. We left after being there for 20 minutes. Read more

I would not recommend this place. The pizza is not bad but service was hortible- slow, inaccurate, and inhospitable. I observed... that they serve their white clients more efficiently than others. Sad in this day and age Read more

This use to be my favorite restaurant but now I don’t know. I’m not sure if they hired new chefs but the food tastes much... different. Mozzarella sticks are usually so good and now are too crunchy, penne alla vodka is too creamy, only thing that tastethe same is the pizza. It’s very upsetting and I hope they relearn their now old fan favorite recipes. Read more

Havent been there in years used to be good. Waitress annoyed for whatever reason or maybe because we took pizza to go. Empty... except for 4 other people sitting outside. Rude waitress starts ringing us up at the register while we were still ordering bypizza case. We're standing right there but guy yells something & slammed box down. Got home 5 min away pizza is cold. :( Read more

The food was just okay, calamari was unseasoned, pasta was alright? and the meat I got from my pasta felt like it was from... yesterday, very hard. Not really worth the long wait and price imo Read more