Reviews for Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe in Milan, IL
The Italian Stallion with an amazing dry red wine is one our favorite guilty pleasures! We make the 30 minute drive to bring... this pizza home for a nice movie night regularly. The dine In experience is great too! We just love Pagalo?s. Thank you foralways providing a quality pizza that?s worth every penny! Read more
This is a great little pizzeria. The toasted ravioli is excellent and the pizza is outstanding. The pizza crust has just a... little bit of a chew to it, almost like a muffuletta-style bread, but is still crispy. It's a wonderful combination for a pizzacrust. Read more
I was there for the first time today to meet friends for lunch and cards. The salad I ordered was delicious and reasonably... priced. Our server, Sam, was delightful despite the place being very busy. I am looking forward to my next visit. I highlyrecommend this restaurant. Read more
Great food....service sucks. Last time I was here the hostess was visibly upset for not tipping her for simply handing me a... pizza box. Just 2 minutes ago the one working right now, barely acknowledged my presence, and seemed openly annoyed sheactually had to do her job. Get some better employees to match the food, and things would ne great Read more
Widest variety of pizza options in the region. Consistently excellent food. Bring a jacket, the dining area is cold. The big... wood fired oven causes the temperature imbalance. Read more
Cocktail was pretty heavy on the mixer, but the margarita was only like $5 or $6 so no big expectations. The Caesar salad... dressing was kinda sugary, and it would've been made better with a little lemon juice. Pizzas were not terrible, but just ok.Service was EXCELLENT. Read more
Stopped here for lunch while in town based on a recommendation and really enjoyed the lunch. The restaurant was very clean and... modern with nice decor (see pictures), the workers were all very friendly and the place was quite lively. I ordered the grilledchicken pizza (see picture) and really liked the seasoning, crust and overall flavor. Unfortunately, I didn't save room forgelato after the pizza...so will save that for the next visit. Food: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Value: 4 Service: 4 If you found thisreview helpful, please click to show your support. ???????????? Read more
This place is awesome and has great food, a great atmosphere, and some of the best wait staff and pizza makers I have even come... across in the quad cities. It's unique and delicious. We love the sausage and garlic bread sticks.... Do not forget thedessert... Tiramasu and Gelato! YUM-O Read more