Reviews for Nickelo's Pizza in Milan, IN
The pizza was ok. Definitely didn't live up to the reviews. Probably wouldn't go again for pizza. Does have a nice atmosphere.
The pizza and hoagies are delicious. Service was good. Will be going back to try more menu items.
Ordered pizza x3 over a 2 year period. Pizza is bland, no taste. Price is to high. Pepperoni large tax and tip 20 bucks. Hoping... for new management and taste to change. Will never order again. Read more
Ordered meat lovers pizza, breadsticks, bone-in buffalo wings and pepper jack cheese cubes. Food was fantastic!! Wings were... perfect! Service was really good! We will be back! Read more
Anyone from way back when ziggy were ziggy's, knows the ziggy's are not the same... blah... they are laid flat on a pan with... cheese, placed in the oven and the cheese is a hard flat brown piece when it comes out.. what happened to the yummy pile offries that had lots of melted cheese on top.... no brown hard cheese served with ice cold pizza sauce. The hoagy buns aren'ttoasted, just soft when u get them. Very bummed. Won't be back. Been going to nickelos since 1990.... Read more
This used to be a great place for pizza, but it has gone downhill. Called to place an order for pick-up .I had to call 3 times... because the first 2 times once the call was connected, I was hung up on. I finally got to place my order,and I was told it wouldbe 30 minutes. I arrived about 30 minutes later and they could not find my order. It turned out the girl who took the orderforgot to put it in. I left....they did not even care. The previous time I placed an order I was told it would 25-30 mints. Iarrived about 25 minutes later and was told it would be about another 15 minutes. Know I wonder if they forgot that order also. Read more
The best restaurant in the world! It has the one of a kind flavor that you just can't get elsewhere. And when you go, you get... one of everything! Lol. Read more
I've been coming here and the previous location up the street for 20 plus years. Love their food. Amazing cheese! I would drive... to Milan, when I lived in Indianapolis, just to get their pizza! Happy I loved home and can enjoy it whenever I want. Goodprices! Did I mention the cheese? Try the ziggy fries, there covered in pizza cheese with pizza sauce. Read more