Reviews for Mama Teresa's Italian Restaurant & Pizza in Milford, CT

Ordered 3 pizzas tonight. 2 were fine but the small xtra cheese with buffalo chicken wasn't cooked well enough. When trying to... take a slice out of the box, cheese and toppings slid right off. Ended up throwing the pizza out. What a waste. Read more

3.5 Good Italian food at normal Italian food prices. The chicken parm was 3 thin sliced chicken portions that were fried... perfectly. The sauce was mild and aromatic. The stuffed shells were melty cheesey deliciousness as well. Everything melty. Mozzsticks were the same. Good stretch on the cheese and a nice golden fry. Very interesting vibe inside. It feels like a dineralmost. A Perkins or something old people like. Read more

(8/27/22) Ordered a large extra cheese and pepperoni. Came to $23. The pizza is fine. Very droopy crust and lots of grease. It... wasn't burnt, which I noticed many pizza places around here have a problem with. Read more

Food always taste fresh, presented well and taste delicious,. However, its very noticeable and disappointing that they... continuously decrease their portions while steeply increasing the prices. They provide less sauce and meat particularly for takeout; they no longer fill the 2 oz cups to the top with sauce. Totally annoying they've increased prices and decreased portions. Read more

Very good pizza and pasta. All pizzas were really good except for the veggie pizza, too soggy, can't even hold it by hand as it... it falls off. Great staff ordering out or eat in. You can ask for thin crust. Read more

Def in my top 5 dining spots. Even lunch specials are great. You can order anytbing from pizza... wings.. to a steak.. calamari ... and sexy Italian food. Our go to spot with or without kids. And they accommodate big groups. Always leave full Read more

Gnocchi was so over cooked it was mushy and the flavor was terrible, I couldn't even it eat. The bolgnese sauce was good and... the chicken soup was delicious. $75 for 2 people with no drinks seemed a bit pricey. Read more

Standard Italian cuisine which serves some fresh and quality food. Staff and management are really good. Service is quick and... they all r helpful. Coming to food - there Pizzas are delicious. Lots of specialty dishes to try out to. Read more