Reviews for Captains Pizza & Restaurant in Millsboro, DE

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza tonight and I asked for a little extra sauce...when I went in to pick up my pizza the 2... younger boys that waited on me started laughing when I told them the name on the order, I didn't think to much about it till Igot home and opened my pizza...it was sooooooo much sauce you could barley see the cheese and someone dumped salt (or garlicsalt) all over it...it was uneatable!!!! I have never been so upset at a restaurant...smfh I could've delt with all the saucebut why put salt all over the pizza!!! Never will I ever go there again...Young kids that play with people's food isn't funny atall...1st and last visit there???? Read more

Best pizza in the area. Ordered delivery. Second time ordering. Delivered on time in 45 minutes. Workers had pineapple pizza... which they enjoyed. I had a Chicken wrap which was good. Will continue to order from Captains. Thanks for the prompt service andgood food! Read more

I have had food delivered and have dined at the restaurant. Huge menu, terrific food and decent portions at a fair price for... this resort area. Wish I could give 5 stars, but delivery on weekends can take 90 minutes and food was barely warm. Best to callin and pickup on weekends. Read more

The pizzas are, I think, the best in the County (possibly the State). I ordered take out heading there as soon as the order was... placed (they said 15-20 minutes); with a 5 minute drive home the side of the box was a gross exaggeration, it said: Fresh HotPizza. I'll assume it was fresh; but, even at pickup it was NOT hot within anybody's imagination. The pizzas are GREAT when theyare hot; okay when a tad warm. Bloody annoyed!! Read more

Wow is all I can say. It was pretty bad this time. We ordered seafood feast it had only shrimp not the seafood described in the... menu. We also ordered Greek fries. They were awful. They were so greasy and wet they weren't edible. We were definitelydisappointed. ???? Read more

Our first time there. We had eggplant parmesan and Captains Cajun special. Waited a bit longer than usual, but that proves the... dishes weren't prepared ahead and just nuked when ordered. Food was very good and if you leave there hungry, it's your fault,large portions. Definitely will stop again! Read more

Excellent service and delicious food. Calzone was huge and packed full of toppings. The best in long neck!!

Food is delicious! I got carry-out and girl was a little stern but nothing worthy of a complaint. Ordered garlic knots, white... pizza, plain cheese pizza, and a meat lovers calzone. I'm very impressed! Will definitely go back again! Read more