Reviews for Buckhorn Supper Club in Milton, WI
Fantastic food and staff! Wonderful view over the water. I will definitely be back.?? I ordered the lobster dinner. Yummy!
Amazing food, views of lake Koshkonong, beautiful sunsets. What more could you ask for. Prime rib was so thick but tender you... almost didn't need a knife. Halibut well proportioned with a wonderful glaze. French onion soup done right with melted cheese.Waitstaff were wonderful, owners too. It's a bit hidden and deceiving from the street and front. Read more
Beautiful view for dinner. Everything was great. We went with a ribeye (med) and a filiet (med rare) both cooked perfectly and... so tender. The owner was there, a very friendly gentleman who was quick to give the guest wifi password...cell service was alittle spotting at the bar. I would have liked to have seen a relish tray being a super club but not a deal-breaker by anymeans. We recommend and will return for dinner again. P.S. Thank you for making our 31st anniversary a wonderful night! Read more
We called on a Friday evening and were able to get a reservation in 40 min. One drink in the bar, met the owner Matt who struck... up a conversation. Fried perch and fried shrimp was very good. Great atmosphere. We'll be back even though we live about 40miles away. Read more
What a great supper club. Bar area and old fashioneds were spot on. Staff was incredibly friendly and helpful for our large... group. I don?t eat a whole lot of it so there might be better ones out there but I think was the best prime rib I?ve ever had.Sunsets on the lake never hurt anyone too. Read more
We were a group of 6, had a fun time, great sunset on the patio. I had the Prime Rib, King's Cut, which was 2" think, must have... weighed 3 lbs. This has to be the best Prime Rib I've ever had. Needles to say all six of us had some of my PR. Everyone elsehad fish, which is usually my go, but am glad I tried the PR. The crew was short 2 servers that night. Service was slow, butworth the wait. We'll be back. Read more
Great Supper Club We took a drive down to Lake Koshkonong to have dinner at Buckhorn Supper Club we got there a few minutes... after they opened which is 4 p.m. on Fridays we got there early as I had heard it gets busy very quickly which it did shortlyafter we arrived. They do take reservations if you want to go that route. We were seated immediately at our table by a windowwith a lake view and our server was at our table promptly to bring us water and see what we wanted for beverages my companiongot a Brandy Old Fashioned sweet which she said was very good I got Gray's Root Beer in a bottle which was excellent. We placedour orders when the server brought our drinks. I ordered the fried fish with a baked potato with a cup of clam chowder on theside my companion ordered the baked fish with baked potato after putting in our order our server returned with Cole slaw andwarm rolls and crunchy bread sticks that come with the meal these come with small containers of cheese spread and butter theywere all excellent and were enjoyed. My clam chowder was not far behind and it was piping hot and also very good with a goodpercentage of clams to potatoes and not a tough clam piece nor undercooked potato to be found. When our entrèes arrived theywere hot and perfect the baked potatoes were perfectly done and my fried fish was perfectly cooked and the coating was verylight and held up well to the fish my companions baked fish was also perfect and she said it was excellent. Our server was greatkeeping our water glasses filled and checking on us to make sure everything was to our liking. It was a great meal in a greatSupper Club with good people on the shores of Lake Koshkonong and we will be back to try something else on the menu in thefuture like maybe the prime rib which I had heard was excellent we will see about that. Read more
First time there did not disappoint. Bartender was great. Server was amazing and food was delicious. Fantastic view of the lake