Reviews for Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar in Milwaukee, WI

Just wanted to let you know what a great experience we has tonight! I had reservations and was seated immediately. Server was... knowledgeable ,prompt and friendly. Started the meal off with oysters that were so delicious. My dinner companion had brisketand I had the pecan crusted trout and a side of grits. The fish was done perfectly and the portions were more than ample! Icouldn't even finish and had to get a take away container. Thank you for a memorable evening looking forward to coming back soon Read more

I was seriously impressed. Went for an early dinner on Saturday with my family. Our waiter was awesome and seemed to really... enjoy his job which set us up for a fantastic meal. I had the fried chicken. The breading was phenomenal. It had a touch ofhoney and was really sweet. As good as it was, after talking to our waiter I’m honestly excited to back and try theirNashville hot chicken next time. My wife had the BBQ shrimp with mac n cheese side. She really enjoyed both of them, havingspent time in New Orleans she had been looking for good seafood and said she finally found. My son got a burger and actuallyate most of it, so it must have been good. We absolutely will be back and will recommend. Read more

I travel a LOT for work and this is the best food I’ve had in a long time. Every item was perfectly cooked, Drink was... delicious. the waiter gave every single table speedy and charming service. So so so good Read more

I definitely recommend dinning here. I absolutely do not enjoy oysters but the Fried Oysters at Maxie’s are my favorite!!!... Great food, cocktails & live music ???? Read more

We'd been wanting to get in to Maxie's, so in order to get a reservation with only a day's notice, we decided to take an early... dinner (4:15pm). Upon arriving we were seated immediately. The restaurant had just opened, but the dinner traffic had alreadystarted, and by the time we left shortly after 5 the joint was already packed. We ordered two drinks, a Hurricane and a Maxie'sFrench Kiss. Both were perfect. Quickly following the drinks was some complimentary cornbread for the table. Sweeter than mostcornbread I've had, and very crumbly, but delicious. Next up were the entrees (we skipped appetizers KNOWING we were havingdessert (s). Andrea Dexter ordered the 4 piece fried chicken dinner with mashed potatoes, maple braised collard greens andhomemade flakey biscuit. In her words "every portion of this meal was perfect. They have a hot vinegar at the table...make sureyou use it on the chicken." I had the Frogmore Stew, a mix of shrimp, ocean fish, mussels, and chicken chorizo with corn andonion in a light broth with toasted bread. If ANYTHING needed changing, it might be the chicken chorizo, but with that said...Ididn't leave any on my plate. Dessert posed a challenge: what to choose? We opted not to choose, and instead to order onedessert for the table, and one to go. First up was the Bananas Foster Bread Pudding. ANOTHER flawless victory for Maxie's.Perfect texture, great taste, not too sweet, and with some salted nuts to balance it all out. Second Dessert was had hourslater, and was the original reason we had chosen Maxie's as a destination. The Peanut Butter Pie comes highly recommended, andwe can see why. Most peanut butter dessert, in general, are far too peanut butter forward. This dessert, however, perfectlybalances chocolate, a delicate peanut butter cream, salted candied nuts, and a crisp crust to deliver an incrediblebite. Service throughout the evening was flawless, and we could have thrown a dart at the menu and gotten something el Read more

Food was four stars but my take out bag ripped while taking out of car. Collard green juice everywhere. I sent a message through... the website to let them know but haven't heard back Read more

I love this restaurant! All the food is amazing! I try new things each time and now half the menu is my favorite. They also have... the best Friday Fish Fry in town. Three large delicious pieces of fish with waffle fries, can’t get any better. No need forketchup, use the tarter sauce for your fries! Don’t forget to go early, great happy hour deals. Read more

Outstanding service and great food! Came here for dinner and ended up sitting at the bar instead of waiting for a table. The... drink menu is extensive with plenty of cocktails, wine, and beer options. Ordered the jambalaya which was very good but not whatI was expecting. I incorrectly thought it was closer to a stew and not a rice dish. When I explained this to the server heoffered to take it back which was unexpected but much appreciated. Tried the gumbo instead, which is a stew, and it wasexcellent. Great flavors, not too spicy or too mild. Corn bread is light and subtly sweet. Took home the pumpkin mousse dessert,I would go back for that alone! Can't wait to stop by again and try the oysters and shrimp! Read more