Reviews for John Fazio Farms Barbecue in Modena, NY
Really good ribs! Fall of the bone tender and the most amazing moist sweet corn bread! I should have bought more to take home!... The sweet beans were surprisingly excellent as well. The pulled pork sandwich was good but not the best and needed some sort ofsauce to make it more flavorful and the potato salad was really lacking- skip that side. Waitress and owner were both very niceand helpful. Clean bathroom & good lunch prices too; definitely recommend if in the area. Read more
Reviews are overly generous. Friendly owner. Pizzas were about 14" - one is enough for 2 people. Seemingly wonderous... selection disappoints. Good crust. So-so toppings. Piggy Salad: The menu description was better than the execution. Iactually would come back - if anything to support a local - and it wasn't bad --- just not great. We gave it a B-. Read more
Wow. This place was awesome! My husband and I are super fussy about pizza because we lived in Italy and now live in NYC. It was... truly delicious. Tender, nice charring and the toppings were so fresh: you can tell this all comes from a farm. Not overlyseasoned. Just quality seasonings and let the ingredients shine. They accommodated my no cheese request (I know I?m weird) butmy husband said the cheese was incredible, as were the smoked meats and veggies. Roasted garlic was sweet and no processedgarlic salt in sight unlike so many other places. Can?t wait to bring my family here when they visit. Nice beer selection tooand staff was lovely, despite clearly being rushed off their feet on a Sunday night. Loved it. Photo is of my husbands brisketand gravy pizza! Read more
Food was good. I got the brisket, my wife got pulled pork sandwiches. My daughter got a cheese pie. Plenty of food per serving.... Take some home to eat later for dinner. Read more
Great pizza place with award winning wings. Ordered a Margherita and a dozen wings. A nice thin crust pizza with fresh tasting... sauce and toppings. Only knock was the bottom of the pizza was slightly burned. Otherwise the pizza tasted great. The wingstasted good as well. Wings were juicy and the sauce had a nice tangy taste. Pleasantly surprised by this place. Read more
After an afternoon of skydiving you want something to fill you up. This is the spot to do just that. We didn't, however,... expect find ribs AND pizza... have to say that we were happy we made the trip here. Overall, their barbecue is good enough thatit doesn't need the extra helping of sauce, unless you're into that. The brisket, had the classic smoke rings associated with agood slow barbecue, but I feel that I may have gotten the end of it as I didn't get enough pink in my cut. The wings had agreat smoky flavor to them as well and were very tasty. Get yourself extra corn-bread as it's moist and flavorful. The pizzais made by hand, and it's fresh. The crust is crunchy and they have a good sauce for being outside of NYC... lol. That,combined with a good selection of local beers on tap and a bottle of Freefall sangria, with a scenic outdoor dining area, you'relooking to have a wonderful meal that won't disappoint. Read more
Delicious food. Bbq meats so yummy they call off the bone. They were empty indoors so we had the place to ourselves but they... seem to have a flow of customers for takeout. Very simple bbq. Had the tasty duck pizza. Wow. The wings, the fresh potatochips.. and geez the prices were awesome. We are from Brooklyn eating in there with a group of 8 meeting these very good priceswith this amount of food it made us all very satisfied. We will be back. The drive up from Brooklyn was worth it. A greatdinner after enjoying Minnewaska state park. Read more
A really upstate suburban family BBQ place. Best barbecue ever? No, but I don?t think you?ll be disappointed. The ambiance is... fun. There will be numerous dead deer heads staring at you, but it?s fine. The wait staff was very friendly andaccommodating. For the food, the wings are very good. They?re Smokey and the sauce is pretty good. I stuck with poultry andalso had the smoked duck. Very tasty also. The brisket looks ok, I?ll leave that to Texas. The pizza was also just ok, maybe6.8/10. The sides were ok also. The max salad was dry-ish, there isn?t much, if any, mayo. The corn bread is nice, but verycakey. Tip is you can call ahead and get your name on the list to avoid a wait. Read more