Reviews for Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake in Mohegan Lake, NY
The crust was to hard to bite but the rest of the bread felt rubbery. I saw them take the pizza out of the oven and handed it to... me, so the pie wasn?t sitting. It?s unfortunate because the service is great. I haven?t tried the other food but I wont begetting pizza from here again. Read more
Great empanada place! Lots of choices and they have a good spin on empanadas. And there mini calzones is great. This way I don?t... have to eat just calzone because it?s ginormous. It?s a great size for you to try a whole bunch of stuff. Great place.! Read more
7/19/22 update...I cannot recommend the veal parm wedge...a thin thin layer of veal parm...lotta lotta bread...proportions way... off ending up with unidentifiable flavored bread sandwich. Jeeze charge me more if needed but at least make a good sandwich !:=[ 1 outa 5 rating on veal parm wedge. Previous review still stands. Previous: Very good Sicilian pizza (i am generallynot a Sicilian fan), very light with a bit of crunch on the bottom! I really like the calzones, veal n pepper and meatball aremy favorites. Not a traditional long calzone, small squares full of flavor. A bit costly for a pizzeria but I cannot faultany food establishment for being a little costly after the pandemic hit. Read more
Just tried their plain slice -- easily among the best I've ever had; with a taste similar to what you'd find in any great NYC... pizzeria. Better than the 2 other pizza joints nearby in terms of pizza and different offerings (tacos! 3 for 10, gotta trythem!). Read more
Love their selection of Empanadas! Meats, cheese , seafood and even dessert empanadas. Good thin crust pizza. My favorite is the... Meatball Calzone. Read more
Extremely, Extremely disappointment!!! A place I?ve enjoyed for the last 2 years went from a 5 star Italian restaurant to food... That is flavorless and bland , I?m embarrassed to give it 1 Star! I know Covid made them loose people, My Family may order fromthem, but I am looking for another place. To many mistakes on our orders, to miss parts of the order, to realizing there is nogood Italian restaurant in Mohegan Lake! Read more
The calzones are tasty and fulfilling. I bought the chicken, and it's stuffed with lots of protein. The size was a little... smaller than what I expected. If you wanna have something for a snack, then you should absolutely get this. Usually when I getsomething outside my stomach might go a little haywire, but this time I was on cloud nine(it little exaggerated, Iguess) Anyways the food there is good as far as I tried. Read more
The food was amazing. Everything was delicious. Robert went above and beyond. Not only is the food awesome but Robert?s customer... service was unlike any other place I?ve been. I recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for great food and outstandingservice. Read more