Reviews for Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Monsey, NY

This Kosher, partially Chalav Yisroel branch of the franchise famous for its "Ice, Custard, and Happiness" is a great addition... to the Monsey ice cream store scene, bringing the unique offerings of Rita's with it, including the branded cups, free tasting,and a variety of all manner of frozen concoctions. Read more

Love their ice cream, be careful it's addictive!

Mother in law enjoyed her favorite: chocolate ice cream with hot fudge and whipped cream. Too expensive at $ 7.50 for small... sundae. Order counter was not clean. Tables not wiped off. Floor littered with napkins and spoons .3 employees were not all busyhelping customers so they could have straightened up the store. We will not go back. Read more

I was reluctant to go there due to warnings about crowds and poor Covid safety compliance. I finally tried on a school day... mid-afternoon. There were no other customers, but there is a prominent sign requiring masks and the workers wore them. The icestaste great and service is friendly. I will go again as long as they continue to respect my safety. I am also thankful that theycarry chol over stam products as some of us prefer to have a choice. Read more

I felt very racially profiled as a white man in this establishment. The people behind the counter were whispering considering I... was the only non orthodox jewish person in the place. Everyone else was staring at me too. Felt very uncomfortable Read more

Rita's is a great ice cream/ices spot here in Monsey. They have options for cholav Yisroel and non cholav Yisroel to cater to... All markets in the grater Rockland area. Always friendly staff waiting to take your order and have patience for kids to maketheir decisions. Read more

Went to Rita's with my sister and had a blast. The server was kind and informative. We got different types of frozen desserts,... all of which were amazing. Will definitely come again! Read more

Awesome service and great taste