Reviews for Montauk Circle in Montauk, NY
My husband and I stopped in here on whim after I pointed out a sign for espresso martins, which are my husband?s favorite.... Kieran the bartender was absolutely the best we had our whole trip, or just in general. I personally don?t drink alcohol and hemade me a delicious nonalcoholic drink, it really made me feel included. It was nice to not order a soda at a bar for a change! The calamari was also great and super crispy, and this is coming from someone who isn?t a huge calamari fan. Read more
Great spot for a quick bite and drink. We ordered the lobster roll and something else and they were both great. It's a bar, so... don't expect fine dining, but totally worth stopping by. Gets busy at night so make sure to plan ahead. Read more
My husband and I were in Montauk for the weekend of Sept. 24th and saw Montauk Circle advertised in the local paper and decided... to try it. So glad we did. They had a 4 piece band called Bingo Bango playing outside and they were great! The place is veryclean, nice ambiance and good burgers. I wanted to especially mention Kiernan the bartender. He is one of the best bartenders Ihave ever had serve me. He was top notch and very friendly. Would highly recommend going for a few drinks and if you're hungry,dinner is good as well. Read more
Service was pleasant. Food was OVER PRICED and NOT good! My friend ordered the fish and chips and the fish gave her horrible... food poisoning on the train en route back to the city. Her cocktail also sucked. I ordered the Asian chicken wings and they werejust gross, overly saucy and the chicken was so greasy and not nicely cooked, like it was slimy on the inside; not a nicetexture. I had just one and was so disgusted. In addition, my husband asked to make sure there was no bloody cilantro on thewings and sure enough, my first bite and it was a mouthful of cilantro used for garnish that I should have smelled first insteadof assuming it was some other green herb. I nearly vomited from that experience, I can in NO WAY eat the stuff or even taste itwithout wanting to instantly vomit. Wish we could have all gotten our money back. My Margarita was the only nice thing Read more
I paid $36 for a salad and that?s not an exaggeration. I ordered it to go and it didn?t even fill the take out container. Prices... are insane, food is nothing special. Read more
The Circle restaurant had amazing food! Friendly staff and great live music! Also an abundance of nice shops in this beautiful... are. The Montauk Lighthouse is a must see! Read more
Absolute hidden gem. Highly recommend you make this restaurant part of your Montauk experience. Atmosphere perfect. Attentive... and kind staff. Loved the food. Pictured is the watermelon, feta, hearts of palm and gazpacho salad with shaved coconut. Sodelicious. We?ll be back again. Read more
Never eat here. Bro it?s so awful I think its genuinely the worst meal I?ve ever had. $38 dollars for the most bland simmering... pile of dookie I?ve engulfed. We waited an hour and a half for the worst food ever on gang bro that was horrible. I?m nevercoming back unless I can personally slap the chef, that way I can encourage him to stop cooking that real mushy lumpy humpty dumpty sumptuous substance. Read more