Reviews for Pizza Village in Montauk, NY
Calamari was nice and fresh !! Well Cooked and the home marinara sauce was great too !! Pizza was not as expected however... toppings were not shy !!! Staff were great and suggested right things ! We stopped for quick bites after visitinglighthouse. This place accepts only cash if dine in , online pickup orders can be paid by card Read more
Just average pizza not so great,didnt enjoy it, but the calamari were perfectly cooked.
Pizza Village is the place to go in Montauk for your pizza fix. It's a dated establishment that has been around for a long time.... A classic old school pizzeria with tables inside and outside. Very good pizza slices ????, pies and an assortment of Italianfavorites. It's well worth the visit. Enjoy. ???? ???????? Read more
convenient location in walking distance to town. pizza is so-so. usually a last option place. rude service, closed the walk-up... window on a customer a minute after close. the crowd wasnt pleased. (2) stars for location & convenience. (2) stars for pizza.(0) stars for staff/service Read more
When looking for places to eat in Montauk, we were looking for a local shop to feast at. Came across this in our Google search... rated as one of the best pizza places in Montauk. This has been open for almost 60 years, so we had to check it out. We orderedthe meat lovers Pizza and a side order of French fries. The shop is just a few hundred yards from the beach, so if you'relooking for a good place to eat while at the beach this is a quick walk away. Or if you want to grab some food to go and chillat the beach this would be a perfect place to go. The pizza was delicious and a good price. Highly recommend if you're in theMontauk area. Will be back. Read more
CASH ONLY * Our duo tried three different slices from the glass case and we ooohed and ahhhhed over every bite. My favorite by... far was the spinach and mozz white slice...so good that I went back for another. My lunch partner had a chicken/bacon/ranchslice and a Buffalo chicken slice, and said both were very good, but the Buffalo was her favorite. We ordered at the counter,had options for bottled drinks, sat where we wanted, and our food was brought to us. There was oregano, red pepper flakes,garlic powder and salt/pepper on each table. Tips were accepted at the counter. By far the best priced meal of our trip at $3 to$4 a slice! Read more
Stopped in for a few slices while in the area for a wedding. Indoor dining was not open but there were a few tables outside. ... I got 2 slices, one w tomatoes and basil, and the other was a white pizza with ricotta. Both very tasty!! And it was fun topeople watch while eating my pizza.???? Read more
I got minestrone soup, awful ! Tastes like tomato sauce with vegetables. No spices, so bland . I rarely review things , but I?m... so so disappointed. I?m hungry and it seems like I have nothing to eat. $ 6 for Small container of tomato sause it is way tomuch . Read more