Reviews for Roberta's Montauk in Montauk, NY
High quality pizza, fun comfortable family atmosphere. Nice outdoor seating (a bit noisy though)
Food was good but service was really disappointing. Had three different people try and take our order. Courses not timed well.... Had to flag someone down after a long time waiting for pay the bill. Weird vibes all around. Probably won’t be back. Read more
brooklyn style in a montauk vibe. delicious apps, great pizza and speciality drinks to match. a word of mouth find that lived up... to the recommendation. server was a delight and food got better with every course. really enjoyed the decor and vibe in andaround the venue. just one slight recommendation, upgrade on the bar games. a must go for any local or tourist. Read more
Food and service and both excellent. We had a white pizza and bee sting. They are thin Neapolitan style pizzas cooked to... perfection. Our favorite appetizer is the asparagus. Not sure why this new restaurant gets so many bad reviews. I feel compelledto share my positive experience. Read more
My favorite pizza in NYC and when in Montauk was excited and surprised to see they had a location here too. Lives up to same... standards. Order the Bee Sting and have a drink. It’s a great vibe and a heck of a great time. Enjoy. Read more
Faithful reproductions of the originals plus some additions. The Stracciatella is fantastic.
My Fiancé and I placed an order at the hostess stand for two personal pizzas to-go. The person working was happy to oblige and... run our card and we were told that it would be a 15–20 minute wait. When I returned to pick up the order, another hostess whowas at the front was extremely rude and told me that "we don't do pick-up orders" despite multiple customers leaving with pizzaboxes. I was confused; they had pizza, and pizza boxes, but for some reason this was an impossible task. The hostess broughtover another staff member who told me that it would not be possible for me to take my pizza to-go. I asked why they had taken myorder (which they were told at the time of ordering was to-go) if they weren’t going to fill it, and the staff memberdismissively told me “I don’t know, but we don’t do that here.” The two women working the front continued glaring at meas I waited for the order that I had already placed and paid for (which was over $60 for two personal sized pizzas). 30 minutesafter placing our order, someone came out of the kitchen with two pizza boxes and bought them right over to me, seeminglyunaware of the “no to-go order” policy that the front of the house staff was adamant about. There were also issues at thetiki bar. I placed an order for a frozen drink that the menu said was $15 dollars. The bartender handed me my drink and said“don’t worry, I put a little something extra in it for you.” I was charged $23 due to a $7 floater that I didn’t orderbeing added (that was possibly half a shot of some local rum). It seems a little deceptive to automatically add a $7 floaterwhen the stated price of the drink is $15. It's a shame, because the restaurant itself is beautifully set-up, and the music andatmosphere are great, especially outside at the tiki bar. But the rude staff, combined with the high prices for pizzas that wereundercooked and underwhelming will definitely keep us from returning. Read more
I decided to come for one hour while waiting for my train. The service was incredible, and the staff made me feel at home. They... were smiley and also kind. The only thing I observed was that the pizza I chose was slightly salty; however, it was not a bigdeal because I had a great time there. Read more