Reviews for Fiamma Wood Fired Pizza in Montclair, NJ
Step number one, whoever you have answering the phone in the restaurant should understand the menu and speak English. It is... really not that hard. There are 1 million places to order pizza from and I don’t need to repeat myself three times Read more
Pizza was pretty good, but overpriced. $23 is too high for a 16 inch plain pie. Eggplant Rollentini was not that great. Chicken... Parm was decent. The front hostess was awesome. She was very nice. It was 5:30pm and there were no people dining inside. Theywere getting a lot of take out orders. It seems many people order the 12 inch pies so maybe pizza is their specialty. Averageoverall. Read more
This was my first time visiting here. I had a taste for woodfire pizza and this place did not disappoint! First, the pizza was... soooooooo good! We ordered the Margherita Pizza and the Sorrentina Pizza. They were absolutely delicious! But the star of theshow was definitely the Calamari Fiammella!!! That was theeeeee best appetizer I've ever had. The calamari was crispy yet juicyand very well seasoned. But OMG that balsamic sauce they put on the calamari was the best thing I've ever had! I ended up askingfor additional sauce to put on my pizza. Lol. I promise you I'm gonna order that calamari again ASAP! Yes, it was THAT good! Wealso ordered the tiramisu. It was ok I guess. But it's definitely Bc I'm not really a fan of tiramisu at all. I just had to tryit again in my adult life so I can say that I tried. Lol. Read more
I wanted a slice of pizza but wasn't sure of they only served pizza pies or individual slices. I waited at the front of the... store for a few minutes as the women in the back pretended not to see me. After a gentleman came from the back door from thekitchen with orders, the young lady followed him up front to where I saw patiently waiting and she never acknowledged I wasthere or even asked if I needed help. The gentleman politely asked me if I placed an order, which I explained to him that I onlywanted a slice. He said no, they only make pies. I thanked him for his time and left. I would never patronage this place if Iwanted a pizza pie as I see the customer service from the young lady was subpar. Too bad, I was hoping to return to therestaurant another time to try their indoor service. Read more
Absolutely perfect. I have to drive by about 4 excellent pizza places to get there, but it's worth it. Not the best picture... because we ate so fast... Read more
We had the individual vodka pie & the fried mozzarella appetizer. More than enough food for 2. I loved the food but the service... was somewhat lacking. I think they only had 3 servers working during peak dinner hours on a Saturday. Read more
Best ever place to have lunch or dinner in Montclair. Great atmosphere, music, staff. Was so happy to discover this place.
Be wary! I went for a quick dinner with my mother on a Saturday night. Restaurant was EMPTY at 7:30pm. Meal was ok - Italian... salad and calamari were good but chicken piccata was overcooked and flavorless. When I requested the check and reviewed it, Iwas surprised that it included a $2.77 charge for using a debit card and an AUTOMATIC 20% gratuity for a party of TWO!!!!! WhenI questioned the automatic gratuity, the nasty response I received from the server was “that’s our policy”. I replied,customers should be made aware of the policy prior to ordering as this was a party of two, NOT a large party that would commandan automatic 20% gratuity. When I went to speak to the hostess (who knew nothing of the automatic 20% gratuity policy), theserver quickly went to the back and adjusted my bill. He returned, handed me the adjusted check and said “if you don’t wantto tip, then don’t!” To which I replied, “I was prepared to leave you a generous tip as I am empathetic to the plight ofservice workers, however, I will NOT reward a thief! Such a shame that one person can ruin it for so many. Management - fixthis immediately as your server is stealing! Read more