Reviews for Gasthof Amish Village in Montgomery, IN
Food was mainly like any buffet restaurant, nothing extraordinary. Read sign that pie was $2.50 per slice but wasn't asked... about wanting desert. Later learned we had to go to the bakery (located in another room) to get our pie. Also wasn't toldthere was an ice cream machine and cobbler in another area. We were really looking forward to shopping in the antique storesbut we're highly disappointed in the two in the village. Both had mainly junk, lots of small items, no furniture or anything ofquality. One had crafty items but again nothing of interest. Would not go back to eat. Would not go back to shop in thevillage. We would like to go again during one of the Chandelier Barn's seasonal events. Supposedly there's approximately 100 +vendors and several food trucks set up in the field outside Chandelier Barn's store. Read more
While out antiquing southern Indiana we stumbled upon this place and found an absolute treasure. The food, atmosphere, and staff... were absolutely wonderful! Looking forward to passing through there again some day. Read more
I drove an hour out of the way to visit here. My family stopped by one year and I have craved the baked goods ever since. I was... so happy to share it with a friend. We both loved it. Simple American dinner options, sides and desserts. It is about the sameprice point of a golden corral, but the fresh baked bread alone makes it more than worth it. Highly recommended, go early so youcan get bakery items to take home, visit the flea market and other treasures on the property. Read more
The fish was really good. The mashed potatoes were very thin and the lumps of potatoes in it was still hard and under cooked. It... just didn't feel like a home cooked meal . I was really surprised that they didn't have any pies on the dessert table. Therestaurant itself had a very nice rustic feel to it. Read more
This is an Amish themed buffet restaurant. The food is decent enough and there is plenty of it. I was impressed with the... meatloaf and the fried chicken in particular. Although it is a modern commercial kitchen and bakery, the old Amish recipes arestill used. The bakery turns out some pretty delicious treats with the red velvet cake and blueberry cobbler dessert as myfavorite. Expect to budget around $20 a person but it is an all you can eat. I would return for another visit. Read more
Comfort food buffet is well seasoned and has a lot to choose from. Large Open cafeteria seating with warm colors and country... store offering quilts, cards to candles in restaurant. Wait staff dressed in Amish apparel. Credit, debit and cash accepted.Hotel and little shops on premises. Worth the drive and the stop. Read more
The buffet is right off the kitchen, it smelled like cleaning solution and the floors were super sticky, as well as the chairs.... Dishes were broken and had to sort through a few to find a clean one. $64 for 4 people. The bathrooms were also sticky andstalls dirty and broken. This place was probably a beautiful diamond at one point. It needs some updating and scouring. Food washot and turned over. Wasn?t sure what was Amish and what wasn?t. Kids didn?t eat much. Read more
This is a great place to eat. It's a buffet, with plenty of good food & desserts. Staff are efficient & friendly, it also has a... gift shop. Give this place a try, it will not disappoint! Read more