Reviews for Abe's Pizza in Monticello, IN

Laud Williams 1 year ago

Great spot! Food is amazing. The breadsticks is a must try. Make sure you get extra cheese dip.

Judith Kline 1 year ago

I ordered a 10" cauliflower crust pepperoni with extra cheese pizza. It was good. You need to come try one.

J W 1 year ago

Love the daily pizza by the slice option. Have great sandwiches and salads as well. The bread sticks and cheese are.....so good!

Rich Ski 1 year ago

We live in Rensselaer and go to Monticello a couple times a year. We always go to Abe's and it is consistently GOOD! This year... we have made many trips and absolutely think this is the best pizza around. Sweet "Shirley" our waitress is one of a kind andyou just gotta love her. This place is the best and will return many more times in the future... Try it and you will beback......Promise:-) Read more

Phil Hackworth 1 year ago

Amazing food, wonderful staff. Pizza and bread sticks are both totally recommended. Will be back

Gerald Patrick 1 year ago

Stopped in here to have a pizza before checking in at Indiana Beach. The whole experience was awesome. Great pizza and staff.... Thank you Read more

Benji Craig 1 year ago

Pizza was decent but the service was lacking. Allowing 3 other walk-in customers to get their orders before you get mine to me... is not cool. I would be understanding but when you then tell me my order is still 20 minutes out when I inquire means you forgotabout it. Just admit your mistake. Don't tell me it just takes that long. I worked for 4 years in a pizza joint....I know. Read more

LaDawna Roberts 1 year ago

Don't go here if you're in hurry. Took forever. Husband's sandwich was not toasted like the girl said it would be. He doesn't... like cold sandwiches. My Pizza's crust was little tough. Breadsticks was very good. Our friends had a deep dish that theyloved very much. Read more