Reviews for Monticello Bagel Bakery in Monticello, NY
I tend to be a strict critic when it comes to food, not known for overpraising. But this place I can't rate high enough. The... fresh bagel and cream cheese I had yesterday was phenomenal, and the Chicken Cordon Bleu sandwich I just ordered is one of thebest deli sandwiches I have ever had, and easily the best I've had in a very long time. This place is simply a MUST-GO if youare anywhere in the Monticello area. Read more
Best Bagels Hands Down. Made fresh daily. A must try if your in the area. You won't be disappointed.
Was looking forward to trying their bagels while I was in town. Finally got our food, my bf got a monster sandwich, the meat was... undercooked otherwise good. My first bagel was okay. I wanted an everything bagel so I went back, used the drive thru. Orderedan everything bagel toasted with butter and cc . The bagel was very dry no butter, the cream cheese was hard and globbed on, itwas sloppy and had cream cheese on the package that got all over my pants. Very disappointed with my experience. Overall, theeffort put into our food was poor the bagel it's self was delicious but lacked butter and cream cheese that was soft the meatand hash brown were under cooked and the bagel was dry and poorly made. Read more
Fresh bagels are really good, lox spread is weak, chicken salad is pretty good, needs extra seasoning. Super nice people working... here! Drive thru is fast but no hot food. Read more
Absolutely awesome! Bagels we're fresh, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. Was recommended by a friend and had to try it... out, you know it's a hot spot when you go at noon on a Sunday and the line is out the door. I will definitely be coming back! Read more
Been getting fresh bagels here for many years. Taste awesome, especially with bacon, egg n cheese. Staff is aways superb as well... !! My family came up to visit from Alabama and took a dozen back with them. Good thing TSA didn?t try to take them away., Theywould have made front page news next day. Read more
Besides charging us for 2 extra bagels, and a container of lox (which wasn?t even in the bag). The bagels we did order were... amazing! Delicioussssas! We got the monster, and lox and cream cheese. Best bagels I?ve had in my life. Even ordered anotherMonster. Better bagels than the city. Coffee was pretty freakin great too. What a gem. Read more
Great bagels and friendly staff! Only giving 4 stars because the meat on my monster breakfast sandwich was incorrect, but the... sandwich was so good (and we were on the road passing through) that I didn?t mind! Feedback for the staff: keep doing whatyou?re doing but read back the details of customer?s orders. ???? Read more