Reviews for Columbia Inn in Montville, NJ
I heard great reviews on this place but I would say it was good but not great. The pizza was very thin and crispy but definitely... didn't have enough sauce. One slice had a little more sauce than the others and that was by far the best slice I had Read more
Pizza Truck Catering was amazing. We had the truck come to our house for a 50 plus person party for my 13 year old son. From... pre-planning through the time they drove away everything was excellent. Our guests loved the pizza and the guys working thetruck were awesome. So was the woman who helped us w planning. If you are looking at adding a food truck to a party bookColumbia Inn. Thank you ! Read more
The thin crust pizza is to die for. My wife and I always stop for lunch or dinner when I’m the area. Great staff and bar... tenders. The owner is always about checking on everyone. Definitely need to check this place out. Read more
Last night, 6/21/2022 I ordered 3 pizza 2 calamari and 2 eggplant rollatini. Very disappointed. Food received was cold. Pizzas... were skimpy on sauce and cheese. Shrimp scampi pizza was just alright. Normally food is great when bringing in from restaurant.They must have waited a long time to call after food done. I just live next block over from establishment. Asked to please notput top on calamari to avoid being soggy, but did anyway. I always rave about the pizza. Cheese pizza is a 9.1. Not 8.7. Forover $100.00, I should receive top notch product. Hopefully next time, there will be an improvement. I raved to my guest abouthow great everything usually is. They were not impressed. May be a while before I order again. Sorry guys, let’s be betternext time. Don’t like cold food. Read more
Excellent thin crust pizza! Excellent wine! Nice atmosphere. Desserts not so good. (avoid the strawberry shortcake)
Bread service is good and comes out quick and no question; when done they brought another one. Pitcher of water left at the... table - love that because we drink alot of water. Food was great - like the carrot puree, wish the portions were a littlebigger. Pizza is very thin- not as filling, but very good. Service was attentive, quick and efficient. Our server felt likefamily. Read more
Decided to try based on the reviews and it was definitely amazing. They have a lot of parking and staff was polite and nice. The... salad we had was delicate and magnificent in flavors and texture. The main entrée very luscious in flavor and presentation. Wewill love to go back and try their pizza. Thanks! Read more
I went there for the first time tonight and it was great. The hostess was nice and our waitress was very attentive. While some... describe it as “too loud” and “anxiety provoking” I found the experience to be delightful and the food was delicious.The calamari was tender and fresh and roasted garlic pizza was full of flavor. Read more