Reviews for Millie’s Old World Meatballs & Pizza in Morristown, NJ

Fantastic, pizza and meatballs and also their salads are to die for! Wonderful owners and staff everyone was so friendly and... welcoming! Read more

Purchased one meatball platter, comprising of what was supposed to be two meatballs and mozzarella slices, and one salad with... chicken. Totaled ~$50 after tip. The salad with chicken was fine, nothing extra special about it, what I expected and waspleased with it. However, the meatballs were incredibly disappointing and the order was incomplete as it was missing themozzarella slices. The meatballs' sizes were alarmingly small for an Italian restaurant whose claim is to be a meatball spot --they were smaller than a baseball. To add insult to injury, they were lukewarm. I threw the meatballs in the microwave after thesecond bite, which dried it out some, but better than eating something comparable to food that has been left out for an hour ortwo over a Sterno. I will not be going back. It was too expensive for the size of the dishes and the quality was generally thatof a fast food restaurant. Read more

This spot was recommended to me by a coworker, you had the choice of wood fire or coal fire... We had a meat lovers pizza that... had... Sausage, pepperoni and bacon. Very good I highly enjoyed and recommend checking out Millie's we also had a side order ofthe HUGE meatballs that they are famous for personally I could have passed. They were dry... So I don't see what all the hype isabout. I love that you can eat inside or outside, They have a parking lot in back that's not advertised. Read more

Popular downtown Morristown eatery. Nice seating inside and out. Choice of pizza: coal (individual bar size only) or wood... burning oven. Decent (a bit pricey) pie in a nice setting. A few new pizza joints open/opening nearby soon including anotherEnzo's. Will definitely give Millie's a run for their money. Read more

A great BYOB pizza joint in Morristown. Nice to have the option of wood-fired or coal-fired pies. The White Truffle &... Prosciutto Pie is a must try! The truffle oil blended with homemade mozzarella, parmigiano, and reggiano cheeses, in addition tothe wood-fired char is simply delicious. Meatballs are good but not a must have for my husband and I. Service can be hit ormiss. I?ve had excellent service even when the restaurant has been jam packed. On the other hand, I?ve also had servers who seemlike it?s a chore to simply take your order. Regardless of our server, pizzas have always come out rather quickly, which isespecially impressive as we?ve visited during peak times with a full restaurant. Read more

Has become a go-to when in morristown and are in the mood for a pie, have a few people, and want to stay on the Main Street.... It?s a good place for 4+ people. I?d reconfirm they have your reservation the day of though, it seemed as though they were notready for us (but luckily had tables to throw together). Meatballs - 4 stars. They have a variety of them, but my favorite arethe meatballs in Marinara sauce with mozzarella. Pics in this post don?t have the meatballs. The MEATBALLS WITH WARM RICOTTA,PARMESAN (w/VODKA) are good. Pizza - 4.5 stars. The woodfired pizza is your traditional neapolitan one (smaller than the coalfired). The four cheese and sopressata are our go-to?s. The coal fired pizza has a thicker dough but i personally finddelicious. although it?s a little thicker - it?s perfectly balanced (crunch, softness) and supports the toppings! The mashedpotato pie one tasted oddly delicious. Maybe if they topped it with a hint of gravy it?d be AMAZING (hint hint!). Sandwiches -only tried the eggplant parm but it?s 4 starts. Good bread, good sauce, good amount of eggplant / cheese. Read more

As someone who follows pizza ratings heavily, I was a little disappointed with the "Signature pie", it had a great airy crust,... but the ingredients and flavor didn't meld and it was tasteless. I'm not sure who gave that pie an award but it didn't stand outas much as I hoped. That said, the meatballs were delicious though, the service was great and the atmosphere was wonderful. Read more

Went there for lunch to celebrate a friends birthday. Great place, they have indoor and outdoor seating.. awesome menu, with... lots of choices, they let us customize a bit where needed; staff was friendly n helpful. There's a wine shop right next door sopicked up a few bottles of wine to go with the food as well... Awesome experience over all. Definitely will be doing again andwill recommend to others. ???? Read more