Reviews for The Godfather of Morristown in Morristown, NJ
Portions are so small. i ordered two salads that costed over 28 dollars with delivery free without tip or tax included, and got... less than a handful of salad. I am sorry for having ordered here for take out. Maybe its better at the restaurant because theycan justify their price with the experience of the place...Either way I just thought it was just a bit unreasonable. The breadwas good Read more
We placed an order through door dash and when my food got delivered they had forgotten to give the dasher the salad. They... offered a refund which was fine but we did say we said we were disappointed and really wanted the salad but understood. A littlewhile later, the salad and a fresh pizza arrived with an apology for the situation. We were very impressed by their customerservice and will definitely order from there again. And the food is great as well! Read more
Love Godfathers! One of three great locations. This location is a great BYOB, casual. We've gone for lunch a couple of times and... really enjoyed how easy in and out it is with their private garage attached. Wine store right next store for dinnerdining! Loved their ceasar salad, eggplant parm, and stromboli. Wait staff were very polite and efficient. Looking forward toour next visit! Read more
4.5. Great spot for pizza & chicken parm. Ordered take out, was on time. Open later than most places in the suburbs which is... nice. Can’t give a full 5 stars as I have only tried a couple items on the menu Read more
$40 for calamari and mussels that tasted horrible and were stringy? All the mussels I opened up looked like string cheese, very... bizarre. They tasted absolutely terrible. The calamari was inedible, it was rock hard and chewy, TOTALLY over cooked. Watch myvideo and look at the pictures. The quality of their food has dropped dramatically. I will never order from here again. Read more
Had nothing but a great experience here. The workers were really nice and provided excellent customer service. The Pizza was... really good. Apparently they make their own fresh Mozzarella every day. This was evident with the Margarita Slice. The Sauce wasmy favorite component of the Godfather Pizza, not to be confused with the Francise Godfathers, where its all commercial, notauthentic. The crust reminded me of a more deep dish style Pizza, where there is more crust..Also the crust has more of aregular slice taste and texture than your usual brick oven Pizza as they cook at 500 degrees. All of which make their Pizzaunique. They made the cut for the Morris County Tournament of Pizza on the Pizza Hunters App. Read more
Went in after being on the Green (right down the street). They had inside seating spread out nicely during pandemic conditions.... Counter guys were super nice and helpful. Jimmy came around to confirm our food was good and see if we had any questions. Thepizza was DELICIOUS - had one pepperoni and one Buffalo chicken slice. You could SMELL the spice in the sauce before you eventasted it - and that first bite was excellent. Flavor bursts with each bite and just an enjoyable slice with fresh ingredients.The sauce was seasoned perfectly, the cheese was fresh and there was a good amount of it. The crust was crunchy and was a littlethick (not NY thin and not deep dish thick) but it worked really well. The Buffalo chicken slice had plenty of chicken on it andthe Buffalo sauce was strong enough to be enjoyable but not overwhelm the slice. (Nice job striking that balance.) A greatexperience located right across the street from the Morristown NJT train station. If you're commuting, it's definitely worth itto stroll over and get a slice, or better yet, grab a whole pie for dinner! (The family will thank you.) Read more
I normally love the food here but my husband ordered two salads and a French onion soup, and it cost $50. I think that's insane... and the French onion soup didn't even have mozzarella on top. I noticed things are becoming more crappier ever since covid andrise of inflation. I don't mean to be negative but it's becoming like this everywhere. I understand things are more expensivethese days but we even picked up the order to save on costs and clearly that wasn't the case. Read more