Reviews for New York J & P Pizza in Mt Airy, MD
Yummy pizza I tried. Priced a little higher for wings and kids spaghetti and meatball and plate of frys then I was thinking 38... bucks but it was delicious. I think prices are just going up and spending money sucks. I can't complain about food at all. Very good. We took leftovers home and the kids ate them before I put in fridge. Waitress accommodated a large group so it was avery nice visit for our family. Read more
Food is consistent. They really need to refresh the dining room. It feels dirty and dated. Indoor and outdoor seating. Plenty of... free parking. Read more
I'm new to town and love it here, this is my new go-to pizza joint! Good prices and diverse menu, definitely better than... competitors in town like Dominos, Papa John's, Ledo's, and Vocelli. Fast delivery and nice dine-in experience as well. I haven'ttaken advantage of any of their weekly specials yet but I plan to soon ???? Read more
J & P recently catered our wedding reception and the food was AMAZING! All of our guests told us how tasty their meals were. My... wife and I really enjoyed everything we tasted. Beyond catering, this is hands down one of our favorite restaurants! If welived closer, we would eat here all the time! The pizza is the BEST, mozzarella sticks are crispy and delicious, and they havethe best meatballs ever! The staff is super friendly and accommodating. Everyone who knows Frank loves Frank, for good reason.He is so generous and kind. You won’t regret eating in or taking out from this restaurant. So tasty! Read more
I ordered online. The shrimp scampi was terrible for $18. It came with five shrimp and a ton of flavorless pasta. The shrimp... were obviously old and fishy. They had no seasoning or flavoring other than some parm that might have been sprinkled ontop. When I arrived, ten minutes after the time the order was ready for pickup, I was informed they were out of wedding soup.So I waited 10 minutes for them to make it. The pizza is decent at best. The service was nice, but the food quality is verylow. Read more
So I ordered the shrimp scampi. 5 shrimp with a big plate of noodles. I know people are cheap but “5” shrimp? Now we can... talk about the shrimp. A little prep work would go a long way. How about removing the last of the shell before you smear yoursauce on everything? And maybe even make sure they are cooked correctly? Shrimp shouldn’t be rubbery. The service itself wasgood. They need to stop being stingy with shrimp, they need a better cook, or at least one who understands shrimp, and one whopays better attention to detail. I do appreciate the fact that I received such a fast response from the business for thereview. Looking through my review history and making a comment on it was very unprofessional. It was more of a hurt feelingresponse than a business response. Since you wanted to bring up supply chain issues as a reason for giving five shrimp, perhapsyou should explain to diners that they will be receiving less portions because of the supply chain issues prior to themordering? Have you adjusted the price on your menu for not being able to provide the same portions due to supply chain issues? Iwould wager that is not the case. The server did a great job. Perhaps before you do a response to a review, you should thinkabout your response first. Have a wonderful day. Read more
Had fried chicken sandwich. Added lots of grilled onion, tomato mayo and mozzarella cheese. Really enjoyed the sub. Other had... lasagna. - pretty good. The Stromboli look awesome. Gonna try it the next time! Read more
We are new to the area & tried this place out for a quick dinner. Our server was a really nice young man (wish I could remember... his name sorry!). Pizza had really good flavor & atmosphere was cozy. The only critique I have is the green peppers we got onour pizza were still pretty crunchy. At least we could tell they were using fresh peppers so no biggie & we will be coming back! Read more