Reviews for Renzo's in Mt Sinai, NY
The food is AMAZING and the workers are outstanding. I was able to meet the new owners and they were so extremely nice and... welcoming. I got penne alla vodka and it was incredible, one of the best italian meals I ever had. My waitress was also so sweetand answered any questions that I had. Overall a great experience and looking forward to going back for more! Read more
Considering the new ownership at renzo's everything was exceptional. The servers were very prompt and wanted to make sure our... experience was amazing. The new owners even stopped by to introduce themselves and make sure everything was great. I had thestuffed shells which were delicious. Another member in my group got the chicken parm roll which was HUGE and could have fed awhole family. Very excited to go back and even order takeout! Read more
Amazing staff and delicious food. So glad the two guys (Mike & Garrett) who now own it and reopened 11/11/22 brought back the... original recipes and new ones too. Definitely won't be disappointed. Read more
Original owners family took over the shop, amazing pizza definitely recommend trying them out
Normally I check the reviews before eating somewhere new but I was too hungry this time lol. Normally you don't see a sign out... with the new & in with the old thought it was interesting but didn't think to much of it. Everyone was extremely nice andfriendly. I loved the pizza and the wings. I'm extremely picky about pizza but I'm glad I tried here today it's definitely a goto spot for me. I never experienced the previous owner but the current owner and crew were wonderful. Read more
Ordered Lasagne - outstanding!!! Lip-smacking sauce, large portion. Only issue was due to price - their website had pre-pandemic... and thus pre-inflation prices so I got a slight surprise. That being said, price was competitive. If not for this issue reviewwould have 5 stars! Read more
This place used to be amazing under the previous owners. Not only is the food just meh, but the new owner is EXTREMELY rude and... mean. I have severe food allergies and politely asked him if there was an ingredient in the pizza sauce. He yelled at me "NO!".I then asked if this same ingredient was in the salad dressing and this man went off. He began yelling at me and my Mom tellingus he already answered our question. We tried to tell him that the original question was about the pizza, but he continued toyell over us. He basically threw our pizza slices in a box, abruptly shoved the box forward and continued to argue as we walkedout. Pizza was also TRASH. Will never come back. Read more
Was so excited to hear Renzos was reopening with the original cooks and staff. Went for dinner opening night. We had an... assortment of things from the kitchen including calamari and manicotti that were delicious!! Let’s not forget about theBuffalo roll… the dough is so crispy and tasty! Will definitely be returning soon. Read more