Reviews for Sully's Pizza & Calzones in Mukilteo, WA
I arrived at the restaurant at 8:30. All I wanted was to order a few pizzas. I was informed that the kitchen was closed. 8:30!!... The open sign was still on. The place is OPEN until 9!!!!!!!!. Apparently, not true. I truly enjoy Sullys pizza, but after thisexperience it?s going to be quite a while before I consider pizza from here. I want to point out that by 8:30 they had theentire kitchen cleaned and shut down. I couldn?t help but notice that the guy that told me this dashed out right behind me whilechecking his apple watch as if he had another agenda. Poor way to run a business. Read more
Sully's is always great. The pizza is tasty and the service is friendly. Typically a few good beers on tap too.
We were in a few Saturdays ago and were warmly greeted by the server. We arrive about 45 minutes before close and were told they... did a hard close at 9. No problem for us! We accepted the challenge gleefully knowing we wanted to get a quick dinner! Weordered apps and pizza and each had two drinks and were out the door by 8:55. Mission accomplished and allowed the staff to getout when they wanted to get out by. Great food and drinks as always! Cannot wait to come back for the food. Read more
Smallintimate restaurant. Very friendly staff. The puzza and salad were delicious. The wings are just mediocre like the kind... you can buy in the freezer section of any grocery store. They offer wine, beer, and hard ciders. Read more
The blonde guy overcharged me $6. I guess the restaurant is struggling, or hes going to get a $6 tip. I tip pretty well btw. I... had to re request the sauce and ask for Napkins? Oh and the food was a 6/10 the crust of the Calzone was like a crepe, soft, notcrispy and crunchy it was wierd. The sauce was non existent, (I requested Xtra sauce). Waste of time and money. Trashed it. Read more
Great small town restaurant vibe. Great calzone, with some taste resemblance to an empanada, fun gimmick with how they... personalize it by writing your name on it with sauce can v. . The pesto foccacia appetizer was amazing especially with thebalsamic vinaigrette glaze sauce provided (the sauce was great on everything). Read more
This is the kinda place wherein you find one thing you like on the menu and never order anything else. For me, that's the Thai... chicken pizza. Been getting it at least once a month since 2017, and I don't plan on stopping now. Love the intimate environmentand the graffitied walls. Grab a pie here, then head on over to the adjacent Mukilteo Chocolate Company for some dessert, andyou've had a pretty good day. Read more
Really really tasty pizza and calzone! They were super busy prepping for a last minute event but still sat us and I appreciated... them being so accommodating. The gluten free crust was awesome and cooked well (too many are way undercooked and doughy, or toocrispy - this crust was cooked to the right level). We?ll be back! Read more