Reviews for Leah's Italian Restaurant in Muskego, WI

Ordered take-out from here on Saturday 11/19th, was pleasantly surprised. We order out from here about once a year, yesterday we... ordered 2 large pizzas & 2 garlic bread, it was really good. The girl on the phone was really friendly, in person she had abubbly personality. We will be back here, soon. Read more

I ordered a Caesar salmon salad they were no croutons or Parmesan cheese just lettuce and salmon. Hardly any spaghetti. Will... never order again Read more

Employees are very friendly here and we love the spaghetti with the meat sauce and the garlic bread?? Good pricing for sure!

Love this local pizza place! I've been coming here for years and never disappointed with my food. Nice service, good prices.... Garlic bread is like Mama Mia's. The pasta dishes are great too! Read more

Simply the best pizza and lasagna around, HANDS DOWN! SMOKES EVERYONE! I find it hard to believe your pizza or food from here... bad. It's been great for last 15 years I've gone there Read more

I always love coming here, this place officially has the best garlic bread I have had in my life. Staff is always friendly and... the food has always been consistent and has tasted great every time I visit. Have been coming here for a few years now. Read more

My family loves this place. The cracker crust pizza is top notch. The garlic/cheese bread is really thick, buttery, salty, and... crunchy. The pasta dishes are good too. On Christmas Eve they offer family size carry out take and bake trays. Whenever I'm inthe mood for ordering out Italian I think of Leah's first. Read more

Please let me explain my total review. First is price. It's on a 14" pizza and the price was $17.87 for a two topping pizza.... Crossroads in Franklin 5 min from there is $18 for a 16" pizza and it's way better. Now when eating this pizza it tastes verymuch like Jack's frozen pizza but it's better. But better than Jack's which can cost $3 is not comparable. I'm Italian tho and Iprefer Italian tasting pizza. Scotty's in West Allis is the best. I've heard the Lasagna is delicious here and I will definitelygive it a try. But the pizza tastes slightly better than frozen and it costs $17?? For a 14"? Do not suggest. At Scotty's with"The Great Scott" special you can get two 16" pizzas for $31. And it's the best in the city. Read more