Reviews for Milk Can Hamburgers & Frozen Custard in Muskego, WI

I?ve heard great things about this place but wow did it fall short of my expectations. The burgers were so greasy and small and... the hot dog buns were pieces of grilled bread at best. My kids wouldn?t even eat them. We could have got better food for acheaper price somewhere else. We won?t be back. Read more

We get take out from here 3-4 times a month. All the food is fantastic, I find the prices extremely reasonable for the quality... of food we get. They have a rewards program that quickly adds up to give you money off. Think of it like an automatic 8% cashback at Milk Can. I had the manager waiting for me to pick up my order so that he could make sure I was getting the rewards.They employ the local kids, which is always awesome to see. I have gotten a couple messed up orders out of easily 50+ orders,not bad in my opinion. Mistakes happen, and they are always quick to rectify the situation. Read more

What a great little place to grab a burger! They have great service and delicious burgers. Fries are a bit weak because they... don't stand up to the burgers. I'd love to see heartier steak fries with the signature seasoning. (That would be satisfying!!)Definitely a restaurant to try!! Read more

Unique and clean interior. Excellent service and tasty food. Only issue is the price is a bit higher than similar options.... However, I had a great experience. Read more

Good quality burgers, malts, friendly service and reasonable prices. Burgers come with double patties. Onion rings are big with... yummy horseradish sauce. Malts are topped with whipped cream & a cherry. All that for $31.50. Rustic, barn-style interior feelscomfortable, with a few booths, counter seating. Read more

We tried this for the first time tonight and were very satisfied with our experience. Our food was fresh and delicious and the... service was the best, everyone was so friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back for a good burger and awesome tots! Thankyou! Read more

We were very impressed with our first visit to Milk Can! The fries and onion rings are perfectly seasoned. Their burgers are... also very good, but the melt was next level. The bread was perfectly crisp and buttery and inside was super cheesy. It's likethe cheeseburger version of the best grilled cheese sandwich you've ever had. A+ Read more

Fun place. The staff was very friendly, the food was great! Everything was made fresh. Indoor and outdoor seating. Drive thru... and the gal I chatted with said you can online order. We did have to wait a bit, but they brought the food to our table, checkedin on us several times while we ate too. My 14 yr old son asked if we could go back tomorrow lol. We will definitely be back Read more