Reviews for New York Pizza and Deli in Myrtle Beach, SC

I've known this family operated pizzeria for 16 years & watched their 3 daughters grow up. They use to be a "pizza by the slice"... also, but no longer. They still have terrific salads & of course, serve beer if that's what you're looking for. Read more

Great place! Dined here many times and never had any issues! Prices are reasonable and the Pizza and other food is very good.... The atmosphere has a cool NY vibe and the staff was super friendly!! Highly recommend ???????? Read more

Ordered pizza for take out. It was ready quick and we were greeted with friendly service. Pizza was tasty, the sauce is very... good. Also appreciate that its a good sized pizza. Would eat here again on our next visit to Myrtle. Read more

How dare they call it New York Pizza. This was the worst pizza I have ever tasted. I ordered a personal size pizza and it was... horrible. Not even the sauce was good. The sauce was watery with no taste to it. I was curious to try this place. Absolutelydisappointed. Read more

Local here. Ordered a large pie and 10 wings for delivery at our weekend getaway across the street. The bill was $32 and change... and we gave the driver $5. The large pizza was the size of a small pie at Gino's and it was paper thin. Dough was chewey and thesauce was clearly canned tomato paste. The wings were tiny; way smaller than the dipping container of blue cheese. They were sosmall they were difficult to hold and bite into. They were rubbery and flavorless. It would have been more satisfying to justwatch $37 burn in a fire pit. I wouldn't even eat this food again if it were free. New York would be ashamed. School cafeteriapizza is better. And I'm not even trying to be rude about it. Honestly...it was horrible. Read more

We always come here while on vacation. The owners are nice and have been doing this for years. I can appreciate the old Italian... way of preparing the dough and watching the elderly gentlemen toss the dough and make the pizza. It's absolutely amazing pizzaand reasonably priced. Read more

Stopped for lunch 9/10/22. Ordered a medium pizza. We are pizza lovers! We just didn?t love (or like) this pizza. The waitress... ?Bond? was friendly and did a good job. We should have paid more attention that there was only one other customer in therestaurant before going in. The pizza dough was under cooked and gooey. The cheese was not melted on top. Was super salty andpizza flavor was fair at best. I would not recommend this pizza place Read more

The business owner (I assume that?s who he was) was extremely rude and big feeling. He made me feel like he was doing me a... favor just to take my order. The wings were very tiny and not worth half what they charge. Read more