Reviews for Sayle's Seafood in Nantucket, MA
Great fresh seafood. A local suggested it for us and we were not disappointed. You have to take it to go or eat it outside, but... it is so fresh and good. Read more
This place has the freshest fish and seafood! Everything we ordered was super delicious and fresh! One of our favorites! Not... much seating but a lot of people take it to go! Definitely stop here when on the island! Read more
The food is good! I got the fried clam with slaw. The price is good too. The place was small inside only enough to order and buy... fresh fish, so you have to eat on the front porch if you want to eat it right away otherwise you can order ahead of time. Read more
Nice fried food spot. The scallops and salmon were great. The fries were pretty good. The crab cakes were covered in breading... and were not good to us. But everything else was great. They had some of the biggest lobsters inside that I have ever seen. Thefresh fish case had a lot of seafood as well. All of the seating was outside. Inside there is only space to order and pay. Read more
Ordered a bunch of seafood for the family and they packaged it all up and we ate it at home. Lobsters were pre-cracked... everything was delicious and we enjoyed it! Read more
This is one of those places that is absolutely not high end, fancy, or anything like that. Don't get me wrong....it's by no... means a dump. It is a really comfortable place that serves the absolute freshest seafood imaginable. It is pretty much the bestfish market you could imagine, they also happen to sell some cooked seafood that you can takeout, or eat on the porch like Idid. It's an old house style building, across from the water with a big front porch with granite top tables and plasticstackable lawn chairs. It's kind of like visiting someone's Grandma's house. IMMACULATE food handling, with delicious food likemy Grandma would make ... better than any restaurant....only the best !!! No pretentious furnishings or trappings that end upinflating the bill....nope....nothing pretentious about this place. They do what they do, and they do it right. This is withoutdoubt, the very best fried seafood on the island.....I can't believe I could get a small side order of whole belly fried clamsfor just 10. I don't know any place where you can buy an amount of fresh, sweet, whole clams for ten dollars. I really wantedtheir swordfish .... JUST WAIT until I tell you about that...but really, how often have you been vacillating over what to pickfor dinner?This place has side orders ....but I mean side orders that are inexpensive enough, in two sizes, and the small sizeis small enough, that you aren't talking about the size and price of a whole other meal (just without sides.) I couldn't decide..I was dying for clams, and it's not easy to find good whole clams...but I also heard about their swordfish. By the waythe swordfish dinner comes in two sizes...large and huge. They get it. They really get it. So, I ordered a small side of wholebelly clams and a swordfish dinner. It was the best thing I could have done....oh my...back to the swordfish....theyactually...get this... they actually CUT THE SWORDFISH STEAK from the fresh swordfish. Oh my ....oh my... really. It was Read more
Great place for fresh and tasty seafood! My son, who previously visited what seems to be a hidden gem, insisted we visit and it... didn't disappoint! It was well worth the walk from central Nantucket. The staff was friendly and helped make the experienceeven better! Read more
The lobster roll was pathetic!!! It was bun with a little lobster salad!!! I felt complete hustled especially with the... price!!! Read more