Reviews for Crazy Stallion Pizza Pie Factory in Naples, ME

Delicious pizza! Daily specials. 40-75 minute wait but, worth it. Thick crust. Not greasy!! So good!

We were told hour and a half wait the first time we called, so the next time we were more prepared and called in accordingly. ... Everytime I even try to make conversation with the older woman behind the counter all I get is rude responses. Everyone elsethere is nice, but both our pizzas were almost black on the crust and very tough to eat. Don?t see what all the hype is aboutbut all I can say is it?s not worth the wait. I?d get pizza from the guy at Nason?s beach over this any day! Read more

In a nutshell: Outstanding! We were camping nearby and needed a dinner solution so that I didn't have to cook in the downpours.... Pizza was a perfect solution and this pizza is outstanding! The wings and cheese bread were both delicious as well. Servicewas fast and friendly. My family loves pizza and we all agreed that this was some of the best pizza that we have had. I wouldhighly recommend that you give it a try. Just understand that it is TAKE OUT ONLY as it is located inside of a supermarket. Read more

Their pizza is the best pizza I have had since coming to Maine. We have tried many places here and they always give us a good... meal. Crust to sauce and topping ratio is always balanced perfectly. Every pizza combination we have had, has been great bitefor bite. We love to eat here and they even sell by the slice. Read more

While staying in Poland, Maine for a little getaway just wanted a relaxing night in @ the Inn so decided to take a little drive... and grab Pizza and we found this place Crazy Stallion Pizza, located in a grocery store(convenient), this Pizza definitely hitthe spot,Great Pizza ,Great selection & a Great price,many specials Pizza for every day of the week, Got a Plain cheese pizza &a Spinach and onion both were Very Good,sauce was just a little sweet but I thought it was good, plenty of cheese and toppings.Pretty good for your buck $ Read more

Hidden in the back of the Umbrella Factory Supermarket is this little gem of a pizza place- some of the best pizza I have had in... Maine! They have great specialty pizzas (give the Grandpa Fleck's a try- just trust me!) and the pies are always fresh and hot.It is nice to pop in for a slice, too, at a reasonable price. Read more

Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had. And I lived in NYC for 2 years. The crust is excellent, sauce has amazing flavor, ... and the cheese is perfect. They have every topping you can think of and some very interesting specialty pizzas like poor andrich boys and the bigmac pizza. Dont forget an order to garlic knots. Read more

'CRAZY' GREAT PIZZA!!! The ONLY thing I wish they would do is THIN CRUST!!! Every time I place an order for a "Thin Crust" it... always winds up being just ever-so-slightly thinner than a regular crust - if any difference at all - and I've ordered A LOT ofPizza's from here..... I think ONE out of about 25 Pizza's has been made with an actual thin, crispy crust - so, that would bemy ONLY 'complaint' - if that's what ya wanna call it... :) Other than that, the ingredients are always SUPER fresh & SUPERyummy!! But, unfortunately, to get a true THIN CRUST pizza, I have to drive ALL the way to Windham & go to DOMINO'S - ugh :( Ifonly my favorite Crazy Stallion would just make a TRUE thin crust pizza...... :) PLEASE MAKE GENUINE THIN CRUST PIZZA'S!!!!!!! Read more