Reviews for Panthers Pizza in Nappanee, IN
My experience with Panthers is hit or miss. When they miss, they miss big. I enjoy the taste of their pizza and the customer... service is just fine. But there have been multiple times where we have had to bake individual pieces, after bringing it home,because it was almost like soup in the middle of the pizza. Very unappetizing. They show you the pizza before you take it homebut it's difficult to tell that there's really doughy crust under the toppings. I'd love to continue supporting a local businessbut if I'm going to get fully cooked pizza only half of the time, l will have to give them up. Read more
I order food here about once a month. They make some some pretty good pizza and I have recommended it to several friends.
The pizza isn't boneless. Okay, when I heard the price, my eyes might have bulged a little; HOWEVER I discovered later the... difference between this pizza and others. This pizza has more toppings, of better quality, better crust, sauce.. everythingabout this pizza screams "Gourmet!" They also seem to have desserts as well like ice cream and cheesecake. I can verify, thisplace supports local businesses as an additional plus. Read more
Great homemade pizza! Panther bread is awesome as well. Great value on their single slice meals too!
Pizza tastes like cardboard with toppings. No flavor. Pizza Hut is better and that?s not a good thing. Yuck. They?re also... unprofessional and can?t take negative feedback. Must have a kid running the Facebook page. Read more
Panthers pizza is a great local pizza joint. Very good lunch specials. Regular pizzas are a little pricey, but are good size and... quality. I think the crust is my favorite part, it is thick and chewy and has an almost sourdough-like flavor. Parking islimited around the building, especially when construction is happening Read more
I drive truck and bobtailed in here for a medium stuff crust panther pizza, with onions and peppers. I can eat 1/2 of a large... pizza but this place I could only eat 2 slices. Great place and they are really friendly. A bit pricey at first but I will beback just because I get full fast. Lots of toppings too Read more
Went there twice. The first time, waited for almost 2 hours to get the wrong pizza. Got my money back and left. Second time... waited for over a hour, finally got the right pizza but only after the cashier struggled to find my order. Definitely won't givethem a third try. Read more